AutoCrit Online Editing
Depends
Confidence: Medium
Buy if you're an indie fiction author revising regularly and will exploit the free tier first.
New check
Comparison
AutoCrit Online Editing vs ProWritingAid
AutoCrit Online Editing lands on Depends, and ProWritingAid lands on Worth it.
ProWritingAid
Worth it
Confidence: Medium
Buy it if you write long fiction and want deep self-editing reports at roughly $60 a year.
| Compare | AutoCrit Online Editing | ProWritingAid |
|---|---|---|
| Verdict | Depends | Worth it |
| Best for | Indie fiction authors | Novelists self-editing long manuscripts |
| Who it's not for | Anyone needing deep developmental editing | Busy professionals who only need typo fixes |
| Privacy | No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.³ | No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.13 |
| Support quality | No support-quality evidence in sources | No evidence in sources |
| Public sentiment | Indie writers praise the genre-specific mechanical feedback and ease of use but agree it doesn't replace a human editor.⁹ | Reviewers praise it as a deep editing toolkit that speeds up revision and integrates smoothly with writing apps.14 |
| Biggest gotcha | Low-tier word caps can force an upgrade mid-manuscript.10 | $60/year is a 25%-off sale price; standard renewal rate is likely higher (Guess) |
Pick AutoCrit Online Editing when
- Indie fiction authors
- Self-editing novelists between drafts
- Writers wanting genre-specific feedback
- Writers who also want courses and community
When AutoCrit Online Editing is not a fit
- Anyone needing deep developmental editing
- Dabblers who won't recoup a monthly fee
- Writers wanting a human editor's judgment
- Teams or business use . it's for solo authors
Pick ProWritingAid when
- Novelists self-editing long manuscripts
- Fiction writers wanting style and craft reports
- Writers drafting in Word or Scrivener (Guess)
- Indie authors editing before publishing
When ProWritingAid is not a fit
- Busy professionals who only need typo fixes
- Casual writers unwilling to learn a report-heavy tool
- Anyone expecting the full toolkit for free
- Teams needing collaborative content workflows
Sources
- AutoCrit homepageautocrit.comofficial
- AutoCrit Pricingautocrit.comofficial
- AutoCrit manuscript safety FAQautocrit.comsecurity
- Self Publishing review (2021)selfpublishing.comreview
- Kindlepreneur reviewkindlepreneur.comreview
- ProWritingAid reviewprowritingaid.comreview
- Ground Crew Editorial reviewgroundcreweditorial.comreview
- Allen Tiffany reviewallentiffany.comreview
- Cady Hammer reviewcadyhammer.comreview
- ProWritingAid vs AutoCrit comparisoncontentforward.ioreview
- Tracxn company profiletracxn.comnews
- Facebook AutoCrit Author Communityfacebook.comreview
- ProWritingAid official siteprowritingaid.comofficial
- Kat Clay: Is ProWritingAid worth your money?katclay.comreview
- Jerry Jenkins: ProWritingAid Reviewjerryjenkins.comreview
review