Feeding America
Depends
Confidence: Medium
Donate if you want a vetted, top-rated charity with national reach . watchdog ratings and major partners back it.
Comparison
Feeding America vs Charity Navigator
Feeding America lands on Depends, and Charity Navigator lands on Worth it.
Charity Navigator
Worth it
Confidence: Medium
Donors should use it . it's free vetting before you give.
| Compare | Feeding America | Charity Navigator |
|---|---|---|
| Verdict | Depends | Worth it |
| Best for | National-scale hunger relief donors | Donors vetting charities before giving |
| Who it's not for | Donors wanting every dollar spent in their own neighborhood | Software buyers . it's a free ratings site, not a purchasable tool |
| Privacy | No known breach of Feeding America itself; a 2020 Blackbaud vendor breach affecting donor data is disclosed in its donor privacy policy.⁸ | No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed. |
| Support quality | No donor-support evidence found. | No evidence found |
| Public sentiment | Reddit threads consistently confirm Feeding America is legitimate but repeatedly debate whether donating nationally beats giving to local food banks.⁶ | Reddit threads and opinion writers question its trustworthiness and methodology, while some users still call it a great starting point for charity research.14 |
| Biggest gotcha | Scammers impersonate Feeding America fundraising; donate only via official channels.⁹ | Giving Basket donations may carry fees . check the fee breakdown before donating.13 |
Pick Feeding America when
- National-scale hunger relief donors
- Corporate giving and matching programs
- Crypto donors
- Research-driven givers
When Feeding America is not a fit
- Donors wanting every dollar spent in their own neighborhood
- People seeking food assistance . this takes donations, not requests
- Effective-altruism purists; EA forums debate its efficiency
- Donors avoiding big-brand charities with heavy corporate partnerships
Pick Charity Navigator when
- Donors vetting charities before giving
- Nonprofits tracking their public rating
- Quick star-rating checks for casual givers
When Charity Navigator is not a fit
- Software buyers . it's a free ratings site, not a purchasable tool
- Nonprofits hoping paying improves their rating
- Donors wanting deep program-impact evidence
- Guess: non-US charities without IRS filings
Sources
- Charity Navigator rating for Feeding Americacharitynavigator.orgreview
- CharityWatch: Feeding Americacharitywatch.orgreview
- Feeding America official sitefeedingamerica.orgofficial
- Feeding America ranked 2nd largest charity (Forbes 2021)feedingamerica.orgnews
- How Feeding America turns $1 into at least 10 mealsfeedingamerica.orgofficial
review
- Reddit: Is Feeding America legit?reddit.comreview
- Donor privacy policy: security (Blackbaud)feedingamerica.orgsecurity
- Feeding America warns of fake fundraising messagesfeedingamerica.orgnews
- Feeding America on The Giving Block (crypto donations)thegivingblock.comofficial
- Charity Navigator (Wikipedia)en.wikipedia.orgreview
- Charity Navigator official sitecharitynavigator.orgofficial
- Managing Donations via the Giving Basketintercom.helpofficial
- Charity Navigator Reviews (Trustpilot)trustpilot.comreview
- Issues with Charity Navigator (Reddit)reddit.comreview