shouldiuse.io

New check

Comparison

MyNetDiary vs MyFitnessPal

MyNetDiary lands on Worth it, and MyFitnessPal lands on Depends.

MyNetDiary versus MyFitnessPal
CompareMyNetDiaryMyFitnessPal
VerdictWorth itDepends
Best forSolo calorie and macro trackingCasual calorie and macro tracking
Who it's not forAnyone expecting the best features free . Premium gates themPrivacy-wary users . 150M-account breach history
PrivacyNo known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.10Poor history: 2018 breach exposed 150M accounts; sources report further incidents through 2026.14
Support qualityNo usable evidenceNo usable support evidence in sources
Public sentimentReddit users broadly praise it as an underrated, easy tracker while debating Premium's value and database accuracy.⁴Long-time users still like the core tracking and even UI updates, but increasingly complain the free tier is gutted while Premium prices rise.
Biggest gotchaPremium auto-renews around $59.99/year . weigh the free tier first³Key features keep moving behind the Premium paywall; free tier shrinks over time

Pick MyNetDiary when

  • Solo calorie and macro tracking
  • Keto and low-carb dieters
  • Type 2 diabetes carb counting
  • Switchers priced out of MyFitnessPal

When MyNetDiary is not a fit

  • Anyone expecting the best features free . Premium gates them
  • Teams buying corporate wellness licenses . it's a consumer app
  • Users wanting a social diet community . tracking-first, not community-first
  • Guess: micronutrient obsessives . Cronometer digs deeper

Pick MyFitnessPal when

  • Casual calorie and macro tracking
  • Budget users on the free tier
  • Long-term weight-loss logging
  • Wearable sync users (Garmin)

When MyFitnessPal is not a fit

  • Privacy-wary users . 150M-account breach history
  • Anyone expecting full features without Premium
  • Buyers averse to repeated price increases
  • Users with disordered-eating risk (research flags associations)

Sources

  1. MyNetDiary: Free Calorie Counter With Verified Foodsmynetdiary.com
    official
  2. MyNetDiary's Premium featuresmynetdiary.com
    official
  3. MyNetDiary Review: Is Premium Worth It at $59.99 a Year?nutriscan.app
    review
  4. This App is criminally underrated : r/mynetdiaryreddit.com
    review
  5. Is premium worth it? : r/mynetdiaryreddit.com
    review
  6. Lifetime vs Subscription : r/mynetdiaryreddit.com
    review
  7. How accurate..? : r/mynetdiaryreddit.com
    review
  8. Nice free food tracking app : r/PetiteFitnessreddit.com
    review
  9. Calorie Counter - MyNetDiary | Mobile Application Risk Checkernowsecure.com
    security
  10. Calorie Counter · iOS app: CVE vulnerabilitiesscout.appaloosa.io
    security
  11. SSL Server Test: mynetdiary.comssllabs.com
    security
  12. Two MyNetDiary Weight Loss Apps Prove Best in Independent Studyprweb.com
    news
  13. MyNetDiary's New Calorie Counter App for Wear OSprweb.com
    news
  14. MyFitnessPal Data Breach . Have I Been Pwnedhaveibeenpwned.com
    security
  15. Under Armour hackers obtained 150 million MyFitnessPal accountssecurityonline.info
    security
  16. MyFitnessPal Data Breach: What Happened, 2018 to 2026intheeventof.co
    security