OfferUp
Depends
Confidence: Medium
OfferUp works for casual local sales . furniture, electronics, cars . when you meet in person and pay cash.
New check
Comparison
OfferUp vs craigslist
OfferUp and craigslist both land on Depends.
craigslist
Depends
Confidence: Medium
Use Craigslist for free local deals if you can screen out scams yourself.
| Compare | OfferUp | craigslist |
|---|---|---|
| Verdict | Depends | Depends |
| Best for | Casual local sellers clearing household items | Local in-person cash deals |
| Who it's not for | High-value or shipped sales . scam reports are relentless | Anyone buying high-value items sight unseen |
| Privacy | No known breaches or CVEs found in sources reviewed, but the platform carries a heavy scam ecosystem and user-reported account takeovers.⁶ | No CVEs against itself found, but its brand is heavily abused and one 2021 flaw was actively exploited. |
| Support quality | Trustpilot and BBB full of complaints | No usable evidence in sources |
| Public sentiment | Longtime users praise easy local sales but report growing scams, lowball offers, new fees, and declining listing quality.¹ | Feedback is polarized: cheap local finds win praise while complaint sites are flooded with scam and support gripes.15 |
| Biggest gotcha | Most deals end in in-person meetups; scammers push off-platform payments | Google Voice verification-code scam targets sellers via fake buyers |
Pick OfferUp when
- Casual local sellers clearing household items
- Buyers of used furniture, electronics, cars
- Resellers and flippers sourcing local inventory
- Local service providers seeking clients
When OfferUp is not a fit
- High-value or shipped sales . scam reports are relentless
- Anyone unwilling to vet strangers and meet in person
- Sellers needing stable, predictable fees
- Buyers expecting consistent listing quality . longtime users say it's falling
Pick craigslist when
- Local in-person cash deals
- Budget apartment and job hunters
- Gig workers and side hustlers
- Free stuff and community boards
When craigslist is not a fit
- Anyone buying high-value items sight unseen
- Users wanting buyer protection, escrow, or refunds
- Businesses needing support SLAs or reliable moderation
- Renters asked for deposits before viewing
Sources
- Read Customer Service Reviews of offerup.comtrustpilot.comreview
- Offer up is trash : r/offerupreddit.comreview
review
- OfferUp Buy & Sell Marketplace - App Store Reviewsapps.apple.comreview
- This are the new fees on offer upreddit.comreview
security
- OfferUp scammers are out in force (ESET)welivesecurity.comsecurity
security
news
- OfferUp Fee Calculator (2026)cluzy.appnews
- OfferUp Premium subscription (official help)help.offerup.comofficial
- OfferUp | Buy, Sell, and Discover Locallyabout.offerup.comofficial
- OfferUp Raises $120M and Merges with letgobuiltinseattle.comnews
- Trustpilot reviews of craigslist.orgtrustpilot.comreview
review