Rands Leadership Slack
Worth it
Confidence: Medium
Join if you lead engineers and want free, candid peer advice from 30,000+ fellow leaders.
New check
Comparison
Rands Leadership Slack vs JoT | Jeff | Substack
Rands Leadership Slack lands on Worth it, and JoT | Jeff | Substack lands on Depends.
JoT | Jeff | Substack
Depends
Confidence: Medium
Readers of Jeff's tech and leadership essays subscribe for free; they buy nothing.
| Compare | ||
|---|---|---|
| Verdict | Worth it | Depends |
| Best for | New engineering managers | Readers of tech and leadership essays |
| Who it's not for | ICs with no management plans | Teams buying software; this is one person's newsletter |
| Privacy | No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.⁴ | Confirmed breach in February 2026 exposed subscriber emails and phone numbers; Substack disclosed the incident. |
| Support quality | Volunteer-run, no support data | Trustpilot shows many dissatisfied customers. |
| Public sentiment | Engineering leaders consistently describe it as a valuable, welcoming place to get peer management advice.⁸ | Writers call Substack a great low-cost start, while Trustpilot customers report deep dissatisfaction and the 2026 breach angered users.15 |
| Biggest gotcha | Self-promotion is policed; founders posting startup links risk bans⁷ | The 10% fee lasts forever. Rivals like Ghost charge flat hosting instead.13 |
Pick Rands Leadership Slack when
- New engineering managers
- Staff+ engineers weighing management
- Directors wanting candid peer advice
- Free mentorship seekers
When Rands Leadership Slack is not a fit
- ICs with no management plans
- Teams trying to buy seats . it's per-person and free
- Buyers wanting structured courses or coaching
- Marketers hunting a lead-gen channel
Pick JoT | Jeff | Substack when
- Readers of tech and leadership essays
- Writers starting a free newsletter
- Hobby writers testing paid subscriptions
- Independent writers wanting editorial control
When JoT | Jeff | Substack is not a fit
- Teams buying software; this is one person's newsletter
- Writers unwilling to share 10% of paid revenue
- Anyone avoiding platforms with recent data breaches
- Users who expect strong customer support
Sources
- Welcome to Rands Leadership Slackrandsinrepose.comofficial
- Rands Leadership Slack Code of Conductgithub.comofficial
official
- Product security pagerandsleadership.slack.comofficial
- Best Engineering Leadership Communities, Comparedengineeringleaders.ioreview
- Professional communities and job searchlinkedin.comreview
- Where to post my startup? Channel rules & ban risklaunchwake.comreview
- Three strategies for speaking up for introvertsexaltitude.ioreview
review
- Will Wegert . 10-year community milestonelinkedin.comreview
- destalinator: channel management toolinggithub.comsecurity
- How much does Substack cost?support.substack.comofficial
review
review
review
security