shouldiuse.io

Report

Should I Use Brilliant Directories?

brilliantdirectories.com·Analyzed 1 hour ago·Based on 10 sources

Best Directory Software - Create Your Own Directory Website with the Best Directory Themes to Start Membership Websites. TRY FREE DEMO

Depends

Depends

Buy it if you're launching a paid or membership-based directory and want hosting, themes, and payments bundled.

All-in-one directory + membership builder. Right for monetized niche directories; overkill for simple lists.

Confidence: Medium

$2.9M

Est. ARR (2024)

GetLatka estimate

175

SmartCustomer reviews

aggregated reviews

Yes

Free demo

per site tagline

Offered

Lifetime deal

via AppSumo, terms differ from plans

Value for money3

Lifetime deal exists; plan-tier criticism documented independently

Ease of use3

No-code, but dated templates draw complaints

Feature depth4

Directory, memberships, payments, plugins bundled

Support quality4

Support and founder responsiveness praised in reviews

Security posture3

Bug bounty and SSL; 2FA only via partner plugin

Pros

  • Bundles directory, memberships, dues management, and hosting in one platform
  • No-code builder accessible to non-developers, per Reddit users
  • Support quality and owner responsiveness earn praise in reviews³
  • Runs a public bug bounty program
  • Managed SSL certificates included with hosting

Cons

  • Users repeatedly flag outdated design and templates
  • Independent reviewers criticize the plan pricing structure
  • Reddit threads say directories rarely make good money
  • Two-factor authentication requires a paid partner plugin, not core

Gotchas

  • mediumFeature-gated plan tiers; independent breakdown highlights pricing criticism — verify limits per plan before committing
  • mediumAppSumo lifetime deal terms differ from standard plans; read the fine print
  • mediumGuess: fully hosted SaaS means migrating members and listings out later is painful
  • lowSome reviewers report needing support help to resolve issues themselves

Best for

  • Paid local directories (lawyers, orthodontists)
  • Associations managing member dues
  • Non-technical founders monetizing a niche
  • Lead-gen directory businesses

Not for

  • Simple contact lists — massive overkill
  • Design-sensitive brands wanting modern templates
  • Developers wanting full code control — use WordPress instead
  • Anyone expecting quick directory revenue

Security

No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.

What users say

Reviews are broadly positive on reliability and support, with recurring complaints about dated design and pricing.

The platform is reliable
G2 review
It's a no code directory
Reddit, r/directorymakers

Alternatives

Compare Brilliant Directories with each alternative.

Bettermode

Community-platform alternative reviewers frequently compare against it

Full analysis

Based on 20+ public sources: G2, Capterra, Trustpilot, Software Advice, Reddit, third-party pricing analysis, and official security/pricing pages. Snippets were often truncated, so exact plan prices and review ratings could not be verified.

Sources

  1. review
  2. review
  3. review
  4. review
  5. review
  6. review
  7. review
  8. security
  9. Pricing & Plans | Brilliant Directoriesaccount.brilliantdirectories.com
    official
  10. news

Rate this review

Anonymous. You can change your vote.

Loading votes…

Ask a follow-up

Ask if a use case fits. Answers stay inside this report and its sources.