shouldiuse.io

Report

Should I Use My Subscription Addiction?

mysubscriptionaddiction.com·Analyzed 1 day ago··Based on 10 sources

Monthly subscription box reviews from boxes like Birchbox, Glossybox, Popsugar, and more. Get reviews, spoilers, coupons, updates and more about your favorite subscription boxes.

Depends

Depends

Free and genuinely useful for subscription box shoppers comparing boxes, spoilers, and coupons before committing.

Free, decade-deep box review archive — great for shoppers, but affiliate coupons and sponsored posts mean cross-check first.

Confidence: Medium

$0

Cost to read

Free editorial site

2014

Active since

MSA Quarterly box reviewed Sep 2014

~100/mo

Boxes handled

Founder volume per Bizjournals profile

Closed

Community forum

Shutdown discussed July 2023

Value for money5

Free; funded by affiliate coupons

Ease of use4

Organized categories across years of reviews

Feature depth3

Reviews, spoilers, coupons; no comparison tools

Support quality2

Forum closed 2023; comment issues reported

Pros

  • Decade-plus archive of subscription box reviews³
  • Publishes spoilers and coupons before you commit¹
  • Has published editorial guidelines²
  • Free to read¹
  • Still publishing — reviews dated into 2026

Cons

  • Readers openly question its trustworthiness⁴
  • 2021 subscriber boycott over site changes⁵
  • Community forum closed in 2023⁷
  • Comment moderation problems reported since 2019
  • Sponsored posts mixed with editorial reviews

Gotchas

  • mediumCoupon links are affiliate-funded; the site earns when you subscribe.
  • mediumSponsored content sits beside reviews — check disclosures.
  • lowNo published security page detailing data practices.

Best for

  • Subscription box shoppers
  • Spoiler checkers before subscribing
  • Coupon hunters
  • Gift-givers comparing boxes

Not for

  • Software buyers — this is a blog, not a tool
  • Anyone wanting unmonetized opinions — affiliate coupons fund the site
  • Brands expecting purely organic coverage — sponsored posts appear alongside reviews
  • Users who want community discussion — forum closed 2023

Pricing

Reader

$0

  • Box reviews and spoilers
  • Coupon codes
  • Editorial guides and alternatives lists

Security

No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.

What users say

Reddit sentiment is mixed: readers rely on the reviews but have criticized moderation, boycotted over changes, and mourned the 2023 forum shutdown.

“I'm boycotting MySubscriptionAddiction”
— Reddit, r/BeautyBoxes
“Do you find My Subscription Addiction trustworthy?”
— Reddit, r/BeautyBoxes
“MSA Closing Its Forum”
— Reddit, r/BeautyBoxes

Alternatives

Compare My Subscription Addiction with each alternative.

Reddit r/BeautyBoxes

Unfiltered subscriber opinions, no affiliate incentive

Full analysis

Based on ~40 public sources: site pages, Reddit threads, and press coverage.

Sources

  1. My Subscription Addiction homepagemysubscriptionaddiction.com
    official
  2. MSA Editorial Guidelinesmysubscriptionaddiction.com
    official
  3. Subscription Box Reviews categorymysubscriptionaddiction.com
    official
  4. Do you find My Subscription Addiction trustworthy? (Reddit)reddit.com
    review
  5. I'm boycotting MySubscriptionAddiction (Reddit)reddit.com
    review
  6. Founder Liz Cadman is leaving (Reddit)reddit.com
    review
  7. MSA Closing Its Forum (Reddit)reddit.com
    review
  8. How Liz Cadman Turned Her Subscription Box Addiction Into a Business (Forbes)forbes.com
    news
  9. The Subscription Box Addict gets 100 boxes a month (Bizjournals)bizjournals.com
    news
  10. MSA Quarterly review (Boxes for Days)boxesfordays.wordpress.com
    review

Rate this review

Anonymous. You can change your vote.

Loading votes…

Ask a follow-up

Ask if a use case fits. Answers stay inside this report and its sources.

    Comments

    One queue. No replies. Give a display name first. Limit: 7 comments per day.

    Save a name to write a comment.

    No comments yet.