shouldiuse.io

Report

Should I Use PrivacyTools.io?

privacytools.io·Analyzed 22 hours ago··Based on 9 sources

The most reliable website for privacy tools since 2015. Find private alternatives to the apps you use every day.

Depends

Depends

Works as a free starting point for personal privacy picks, but the original maintainers left in 2022 and community trust is openly disputed.

Free privacy-tool directory, but the trusted original team left in 2022; community now points to PrivacyGuides.org instead.

Confidence: Medium

2015

Running since

Active community since March 2015

3.2/5

Trustpilot rating

From a single review

Yes

Free to use

Site and listed tools mostly free/open-source

2022

Original team exit

Left for PrivacyGuides.org

Value for money5

Free site recommending mostly free, open-source tools

Ease of use4

Rebuilt app-first navigation for finding alternatives

Feature depth4

Covers VPNs, browsers, email, hosting, guides

Support quality3

Trustpilot 3.2/5 from a single review

Security posture2

No public security page found

Pros

  • Free; recommends mostly free, open-source tools¹
  • Broad coverage: VPNs, browsers, email, hosting, guides
  • Publishes explicit listing criteria for tools²
  • Operating since 2015 with active community
  • Funding transparently listed

Cons

  • Original team left September 2022, forming
  • Former team claims current operators spread misinformation
  • Trustpilot 3.2/5 based on one review
  • No public security page found³
  • Whonix forum discussed removing its mentions

Gotchas

  • highOriginal maintainers left Sept 2022; current picks may not match the site's pre-split reputation
  • highActive community dispute over operator credibility; several forums now steer readers to
  • lowFunding is transparently listed, but verify affiliate relationships behind paid VPN and hosting picks
  • lowOne Trustpilot review exists — near-zero user feedback to validate quality

Best for

  • Privacy beginners replacing Google, Chrome, LastPass
  • Open-source users vetting VPNs and browsers
  • Individuals, not enterprise buyers

Not for

  • Enterprise compliance teams needing audited vendor vetting
  • Anyone following the original maintainers' recommendations
  • Buyers wanting uncontested, dispute-free curation
  • Anyone needing support or accountability — it is just a website

Pricing

Website

Free

  • All guides and tool lists
  • Recommended tools often free or open-source

Security

No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.

What users say

Community trust is divided since the 2022 split, with several forums redirecting readers to PrivacyGuides.org.

Who to trust: Privacytools or Privacyguides?
Reddit, r/privacy
Remove mentions of privacytools
Whonix forum
What happened to privacytools.io?
Reddit, r/PrivacyGuides

Alternatives

Compare PrivacyTools.io with each alternative.

PrivacyGuides.org

Run by the original maintainers who split in 2022

That One Privacy Site

Detailed VPN comparison tables, cited alongside PrivacyTools on HN

Full analysis

Based on 22 public sources; user review data is thin (one Trustpilot review), so trust signals come mainly from community discussions.

Sources

  1. official
  2. official
  3. Security pageprivacytools.io
    official
  4. review
  5. review
  6. news
  7. PrivacyTools FAQprivacyguides.org
    news
  8. news
  9. The Future of PrivacyToolsnews.ycombinator.com
    news

Rate this review

Anonymous. You can change your vote.

Loading votes…

Ask a follow-up

Ask if a use case fits. Answers stay inside this report and its sources.

    Comments

    One queue. No replies. Give a display name first. Limit: 7 comments per day.

    Save a name to write a comment.

    No comments yet.