shouldiuse.io

Categories

VERDICT

Should I use Thegiltlist?

Honest viral book reviews for smart readers who want the real breakdown before they spend their money. - thegiltlist.com

Depends. Follow it free if you want blunt romantasy reviews and book-news gossip; there is nothing to buy and no lock-in. Only pay for its editing services if you are an author — prices are unpublished and it is a one-person operation.

Confidence

Medium. Based on ~20 public sources; the product is a solo WordPress review blog with affiliate links and paid editing, not software.

Ratings

  • Value for money
  • Ease of use
  • Feature depth
  • Support qualityNo evidence either way.
  • Security posture

Pricing

Free

Reading the site

ModelNot disclosed
Monthly feesNot disclosed
HardwareNot disclosed
Free tierYes
Editing servicesQuote on request

Best for

  • Romantasy and fantasy readers
  • BookTok browsers checking viral titles before buying
  • Authors seeking developmental edits or chapter critiques
  • Book-news followers (deals, cons, auctions)

Not for

  • Anyone wanting book-tracking software — this is a blog
  • Authors needing fixed prices or deadlines — solo freelancer
  • Readers wanting broad genre coverage; romantasy dominates
  • Teams or businesses — nothing here is a business tool

Gotchas - check before you buy

medium

Editing is paid via an emailed Stripe link; no published prices — confirm scope first.

low

Affiliate links earn the site commission when you buy through its recs.

low

Site receives free ARCs and review copies; independence is self-disclosed only.

Pros and cons

Pros

  • Free breakdowns of viral books before you spend money
  • Romantasy recs organized by spice, tropes, tone, reader fit
  • Active book-news coverage: deals, conventions, viral titles
  • Publishes affiliate and ARC disclosure
  • Paid first-chapter critiques and developmental edits for writers

Cons

  • Blog, not software — no tracking, app, or library features
  • Affiliate-funded; recs can earn the site commission
  • Editing prices unpublished; quotes arranged by email
  • Solo operation — single named editor, no staff listed
  • Genre coverage thin outside romantasy; many categories 'coming soon'

Sources & method

Analyzed 9/29/2026 - 12 sources - No known vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.

official x6review x2security x2news x2

Key stats

  • Value for money: 4/5

    Rating

  • Free

    Starting price

  • 12

    Sources

  • Analyzed

  • Value for money: 4/5. Reading is free; you only pay for editing.
  • Ease of use: 4/5. Plain WordPress blog, browsable categories.
  • Feature depth: 2/5. Blog and newsletter only; no app features.
  • Support quality. No evidence either way.
  • Security posture: 3/5. Standard legal pages; no reported breaches.
  • Yes Free to read Affiliate-funded content
  • 2017 Active since X account joined Aug 2017
  • Quote only Editing services Paid via emailed Stripe link

Pricing

Reading the site

Free

  • Reviews, recs, book news
  • Newsletter (Join The List)

Editing services

Quote on request

  • First-chapter critique
  • Developmental edit
  • Emailed Stripe checkout

Security

No known vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.

What users say

No independent reviews of the site itself; it is cited by Reddit and Instagram book communities.

Full analysis

Based on ~20 public sources; the product is a solo WordPress review blog with affiliate links and paid editing, not software.

Free solo book-review blog for romantasy fans — great to read, not a tool, editing prices quote-only.

Methodology

Based on ~20 public sources; the product is a solo WordPress review blog with affiliate links and paid editing, not software.

Sources

  1. The Gilt List homepagethegiltlist.com
    official
  2. Reviews That Tell You Who a Book Is Actually Forthegiltlist.com
    official
  3. Romantasy Book Recommendations Hubthegiltlist.com
    official
  4. Affiliate & Review Disclosurethegiltlist.com
    official
  5. First Chapter Critiques for Romantasy Writersthegiltlist.com
    official
  6. Developmental Edit Services Submission Formthegiltlist.com
    official
  7. Privacy Policythegiltlist.com
    security
  8. Disclaimers & Termsthegiltlist.com
    security
  9. All The Young Dudes Book Deal? | Wolfboythegiltlist.com
    news
  10. LIVE UPDATES | ApollyCon 2026 Day 2thegiltlist.com
    news
  11. Reddit citation of TheGiltListreddit.com
    review
  12. Otherworld Tales related-sites listingotherworldtales.com
    review

Rate this review

Anonymous. You can change your vote.

Loading votes…

Comments

One queue. No nested comments. Give a display name first. Limit: 200 words per comment and 7 comments per day. You can edit or delete yours.

Save a name to write a comment.

0 / 200 words

No comments yet.