shouldiuse.io

Comparison

Amasty vs Commercemarketplace

Amasty and Commercemarketplace both land on Depends.

Amasty versus Commercemarketplace
CompareAmastyCommercemarketplace
VerdictDependsDepends
Best forMid-market Magento 2 storesExisting Magento/Adobe Commerce stores
Who it's not forShopify or WooCommerce stores . this is Magento-onlyStores not already on Magento/Adobe Commerce
PrivacyRecent critical findings: unauthenticated RCE (CVE-2026-53787) in Order Attributes and a mass patch release across 25 extensions; vendor is patching actively.⁵No known public vulnerabilities in the marketplace itself; the Magento extension ecosystem around it shows active zero-day exploitation and critical extension fixes.
Support qualityTrustpilot 4.3/627 positive; Reddit reports mixedNo direct support evidence found
Public sentimentOpinions split: long-time users praise the modules, while others complain about pricing moves and integration glitches.Public sources discuss marketplace operations broadly, but no direct user reviews of Adobe Commerce Marketplace itself surfaced.
Biggest gotchaPublic weaponized exploit for Order Attributes RCE . patch immediately or risk store compromise⁶Extensions are priced individually; costs stack on top of Adobe Commerce license and cloud fees.15

Pick Amasty when

  • Mid-market Magento 2 stores
  • Stores needing niche checkout or SEO features
  • Adobe Commerce teams with dev resources
  • Hyvä-theme adopters

When Amasty is not a fit

  • Shopify or WooCommerce stores . this is Magento-only
  • Solo merchants with no Magento developer on call
  • Teams that won't patch extensions within days of disclosure
  • Buyers sensitive to aggressive renewal and upsell pricing

Pick Commercemarketplace when

  • Existing Magento/Adobe Commerce stores
  • Teams adding payments, security or integrations
  • Magento developers and agencies

When Commercemarketplace is not a fit

  • Stores not already on Magento/Adobe Commerce
  • Small shops wanting a simple turnkey store
  • Buyers expecting a standalone marketplace platform
  • Non-technical teams without a Magento developer

Sources

  1. Amasty official siteamasty.com
    official
  2. Amasty Trustpilot reviews (4.3, 627 reviews)nz.trustpilot.com
    review
  3. Amasty seller rating on G2 (3.4/5, 7 reviews)g2.com
    review
  4. Sansec: Amasty patches dozens of extensions, 2 criticalsansec.io
    security
  5. CVE-2026-53787: Order Attributes unauthenticated file uploadpentest-tools.com
    security
  6. Public weaponized exploit for Amasty RCEgithub.com
    security
  7. Reddit: 'gone full money grab' pricing threadreddit.com
    review
  8. Amasty company profile, ~$20M revenueowler.com
    news
  9. Amasty Crunchbase profile, Adobe Exchange partnercrunchbase.com
    news
  10. Adobe Commerce Marketplace . Security pagecommercemarketplace.adobe.com
    official
  11. Security Scanner with AI Recommendations (marketplace listing)commercemarketplace.adobe.com
    official
  12. Adobe Commerce Marketplace documentationexperienceleague.adobe.com
    official
  13. Marketplace seller technical review docsgithub.com
    official
  14. Marketing review guidelinesdeveloper.adobe.com
    official
  15. Adobe Commerce Pricing: License Costs, Cloud Feesswell.is
    news
  16. Critical security fix in Stripe Payments for Magentolinkedin.com
    security