New check

Comparison

Bitcoin Taxes vs CoinTracking

Bitcoin Taxes and CoinTracking both land on Depends.

Bitcoin Taxes

Depends

Confidence: Low

A plausible fit if you actively trade crypto across exchanges and need organized tax reporting.

Read the full report

CoinTracking

cointracking.info

Depends

Confidence: Medium

Buy if you actively trade across many exchanges and need serious tax reports; the free tier lets you test first.

Read the full report

Bitcoin Taxes versus CoinTracking
Compare	Bitcoin Taxes	CoinTracking
Verdict	Depends	Depends
Best for	Active crypto traders	Active multi-exchange traders
Who it's not for	Buy-and-hold-only bitcoin owners	Casual holders with few trades
Privacy	No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.^⁴	ISO/IEC certified and pen-tested, but a 2025 third-party email breach triggered phishing sent in CoinTracking's name.¹²
Support quality	No support evidence found	No rating evidence in sources
Public sentiment	Direct product feedback is scarce; Reddit crypto-tax threads show widespread confusion rather than tool opinions.^²	Long-time users value its exchange coverage and tax depth, but small traders call the pricing unfair and overall sentiment is mixed.
Biggest gotcha	No security page found . verify data handling before granting exchange API access^⁴	Third-party SendGrid compromise (Nov 2025) sent phishing in its name; rotate API keys¹²

Pick Bitcoin Taxes when

Active crypto traders
Multi-exchange investors
Filers with hack-loss claims

When Bitcoin Taxes is not a fit

Buy-and-hold-only bitcoin owners
People with a handful of transactions
Anyone unwilling to share exchange API keys
Enterprises needing audited security posture

Pick CoinTracking when

Active multi-exchange traders
Traders needing full tax reports
Firms (corporate pricing tier)
Guess: DeFi power users

When CoinTracking is not a fit

Casual holders with few trades
Anyone whose gains are under $199
Users wanting one-click simple tax filing
Privacy-first users . Reddit debates its data handling

Sources

9 Best Crypto Tax Software [2026]bitbo.io
review
Reddit r/bitcointaxesreddit.com
review
How Bitfinex losses are taxed - Bitcoin Taxesbitcoin.tax
official
Bitcoin Taxes Security pagebitcoin.tax
security
Crypto Tax Bill Just Changed: What the New US Rules Meanbitcoinfoundation.org
news
Understanding the Basics of Bitcoin Taxes [US 2026] - CoinTrackingcointracking.info
news
Bitcoin Taxes Explained: What Investors Need to Know - VanEckvaneck.com
news
IRS: We have information that you have or had one or more...reddit.com
review
CoinTracking: The Crypto Tax Calculator & Portfolio Trackercointracking.info
official
Crypto Tax Plans for Every Portfolio Sizecointracking.info
official
CoinTracking Security Measurescointracking.info
security
Security Notice: Unauthorized SendGrid Email Activitycointracking.info
security
Multiple crypto companies warn customers of phishingtherecord.media
news
CoinTracking vs Cryptio (2026): Scores, Reviews & Verdictrfp.wiki
review
Anything better than coin tracker? ($199 complaint)reddit.com
review
CoinTracking for crypto tax - love/hatereddit.com
review