ClockShark
Depends
Confidence: Medium
Buy if you run a construction or field-service crew needing GPS clock-ins, job costing, and payroll integrations.
New check
Comparison
ClockShark vs Clockify
ClockShark lands on Depends, and Clockify lands on Worth it.
Clockify
Worth it
Confidence: High
Buy it if you need cheap, easy time tracking . the free plan alone covers most small teams and freelancers.
| Compare | ||
|---|---|---|
| Verdict | Depends | Worth it |
| Best for | Construction and roofing crews | Freelancers billing hourly |
| Who it's not for | Office-only teams . GPS features wasted | Teams needing deep project management |
| Privacy | No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.⁹ | No public CVEs found against Clockify's core product; it runs a bug bounty. |
| Support quality | Human support testimonials, though vendor-published | Lockout complaint plus 1-star Trustpilot reports |
| Public sentiment | Reviewers and Reddit users broadly praise ease of use and fit for field crews, while competitors' reviews flag price and mixed construction-user experiences.⁴ | Most users praise Clockify as easy and affordable time tracking, with recurring complaints about access lockouts and basic project features. |
| Biggest gotcha | Starts at $40/mo base before per-employee fees; costs climb fast with bigger crews10 | One team reported a sudden lockout from their account and rebuilt their own tracker. |
Pick ClockShark when
- Construction and roofing crews
- Field service companies with mobile workers
- Job costing by site
- Teams on ADP or Sage payroll
When ClockShark is not a fit
- Office-only teams . GPS features wasted
- Budget buyers wanting a free plan
- Enterprises needing full HCM suites like Rippling
- Very small teams . a spreadsheet or Homebase is cheaper
Pick Clockify when
- Freelancers billing hourly
- Small-to-mid teams wanting free timesheets
- Agencies tracking client billables
- Nonprofits tracking grant hours
When Clockify is not a fit
- Teams needing deep project management
- Anyone who can't risk sudden account lockouts
- Managers imposing tracking top-down (morale friction)
- Buyers uneasy with activity-monitoring features
Sources
- ClockShark . official siteclockshark.comofficial
- ClockShark Pricingclockshark.comofficial
- ClockShark Job Costingclockshark.comofficial
- G2 . ClockShark Reviewsg2.comreview
- Capterra . ClockShark Reviewscapterra.comreview
- Workyard . ClockShark review (6.5/10)workyard.comreview
- BuddyPunch . ClockShark review (4/5)buddypunch.comreview
- Connecteam . Honest ClockShark Reviewconnecteam.comreview
- People Managing People . ClockShark reviewpeoplemanagingpeople.comreview
- MyQuoteIQ . ClockShark starting pricemyquoteiq.comreview
- Punch . Homebase vs ClockShark pricingpunchapp.ioreview
review
- ADP Marketplace . ClockShark integrationapps.adp.comofficial
- Clockify . free ClockShark alternativeclockify.mereview
- StatusGator . ClockShark uptimestatusgator.comsecurity
- An Honest Review of Clockify (OnTheClock)ontheclock.comreview