F1000Research
Depends
Confidence: Medium
Publish here if you need fast, citable, open-access output . datasets, negative results, or funder-mandated open research.
New check
Comparison
F1000Research vs eLife
F1000Research and eLife both land on Depends.
eLife
Depends
Confidence: Medium
eLife is a non-profit scientific journal, not software . 'buying' means submitting research and paying a publication fee.
| Compare | ||
|---|---|---|
| Verdict | Depends | Depends |
| Best for | Fast, citable publication for datasets and methods | Life-science researchers |
| Who it's not for | Researchers chasing tenure-committee prestige brands | Software buyers . this is a journal, not a tool |
| Privacy | No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.⁶ | No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed. |
| Support quality | No support evidence in sources | No author-support evidence found |
| Public sentiment | Researchers on Reddit and ResearchGate praise the fast, transparent model but repeatedly question its rigor and prestige versus traditional journals. | Academics praise eLife's open, transparent model but debate whether its reviewed preprints carry traditional publication prestige. |
| Biggest gotcha | Authors pay an article processing charge; fees vary by article type . check before submitting.² | Reviewed Preprint may not satisfy institutions expecting a final accepted paper |
Pick F1000Research when
- Fast, citable publication for datasets and methods
- Negative and null results
- Funder-mandated open research (UKRI-style)
- Posters and non-traditional outputs
When F1000Research is not a fit
- Researchers chasing tenure-committee prestige brands
- Anyone unwilling or unable to pay an APC
- Authors who want peer review before going public
- Teams needing a software tool . this is a journal, not software
Pick eLife when
- Life-science researchers
- Open peer review advocates
- Funder-mandated open access
- Readers wanting free research
When eLife is not a fit
- Software buyers . this is a journal, not a tool
- Authors needing traditional accept/reject prestige for tenure or hiring
- Anyone chasing a fast, final publication stamp
- Non-scientists or general content publishing
Sources
- Publish fast. Openly. Without restrictions. (F1000 publishing model)think.f1000research.comofficial
- Article Processing Charges | F1000Researchf1000research.comofficial
- Publishing Policies | F1000Researchf1000research.comofficial
- Prepublication Checks | F1000Researchf1000research.comofficial
- UKRI - F1000 Researchthink.f1000research.comofficial
- F1000Research product security pagef1000research.comsecurity
- How Rigorous Is the Post-publication Review Process at F1000 Research?scholarlykitchen.sspnet.orgreview
news
- Thoughts on F1000Research? (r/labrats)reddit.comreview
- Is submitting a paper to F1000Research journal a good idea?researchgate.netreview
news
- F1000Research - Crunchbase Company Profile & Fundingcrunchbase.comnews
news
- F1000Research | Open Access Publishing Platformf1000research.comofficial
- About eLifeelifesciences.orgofficial
- Peer review and publishing at eLifeelifesciences.orgofficial