Publii Forum
Depends
Confidence: Medium
Publii itself is a free, well-liked static site generator worth trying for simple personal or small-business sites . there is nothing to purchase.
Comparison
Publii Forum vs Carrd
Publii Forum lands on Depends, and Carrd lands on Worth it.
Carrd
Worth it
Confidence: Medium
Buy if you need one simple page . a profile, landing page, or email capture . for free or $19/year.
| Compare | Publii Forum | Carrd |
|---|---|---|
| Verdict | Depends | Worth it |
| Best for | Non-technical bloggers and portfolio sites | Personal profiles and portfolios |
| Who it's not for | Anyone needing vendor support, SLAs, or paid help | Anyone needing multi-page sites, blogs, or online stores |
| Privacy | No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.⁷ | No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed; custom-domain publishing includes SSL via Let's Encrypt.11 |
| Support quality | Forum read-only; moved to GitHub Discussions. | No support evidence in sources reviewed |
| Public sentiment | Hobbyists praise Publii's speed and clean interface but report customization limits and occasional sync bugs.⁶ | Users consistently describe Carrd as extremely easy to use and genuinely impressive for the price.16 |
| Biggest gotcha | User reported all local sites vanishing; backup restore is non-trivial.10 | 'Made with Carrd' branding stays until you pay for Pro12 |
Pick Publii Forum when
- Non-technical bloggers and portfolio sites
- WordPress refugees wanting speed
- Privacy-conscious users hosting anywhere
- Hobbyists fine with community-only support
When Publii Forum is not a fit
- Anyone needing vendor support, SLAs, or paid help
- Sites needing built-in forms, comments, or dynamic features
- Buyers expecting an active official forum . it is read-only
- Teams with complex publishing workflows and compliance needs
Pick Carrd when
- Personal profiles and portfolios
- Email-capture landing pages
- Link-in-bio and quick test pages
- Solo founders on a budget
When Carrd is not a fit
- Anyone needing multi-page sites, blogs, or online stores
- Teams needing collaboration or CMS features
- Enterprises needing SSO, compliance docs, or vendor SLAs
- Anyone who will outgrow one page . plan the rebuild now
Sources
review
- Review: Publii SSGtarus.ioreview
- Publii Review - The Light Weight Open Source CMScmscritic.comreview
- Free, Fully Customizable Websites for Publiicommoninja.comreview
- Trustpilot reviews of getpublii.comtrustpilot.comreview
- Publii Forum (questions thread)forum.getpublii.comofficial
- Forum security page (none found)forum.getpublii.comsecurity
- Forum read-only transition noteforum.getpublii.comofficial
- Bug thread: sync failuresforum.getpublii.comofficial
- Thread: missing websites / restoreforum.getpublii.comofficial
- Carrd official sitecarrd.comofficial
- Carrd homepage (archived, Dec 2022)web.archive.orgofficial
- Carrd listing . Marcus P. Zillmanzillman.usreview
- Accessify technical review of carrd.coaccessify.comreview
- Reddit r/nocode threadreddit.comreview
- Reddit Carrd community threadreddit.comreview