FredMiranda
Depends
Confidence: Medium
Use it if you're a photography hobbyist buying, selling, or discussing used gear . the community has a long record of safe transactions.
Comparison
FredMiranda vs MPB
FredMiranda and MPB both land on Depends.
MPB
Depends
Confidence: Medium
Buy here if you want warrantied used gear without eBay risk; expect to pay above peer-to-peer prices.
| Compare | FredMiranda | MPB |
|---|---|---|
| Verdict | Depends | Depends |
| Best for | Photography hobbyists buying/selling used gear | Buyers wanting warranty-backed used gear |
| Who it's not for | Buyers wanting escrow or buyer protection | Sellers maximizing payout . private sales pay more |
| Privacy | No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.⁸ | No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed. |
| Support quality | No evidence either way | Grading and lost-item complaints recur |
| Public sentiment | Photography hobbyists largely trust FredMiranda's forums and buy/sell, citing safe transactions and a real community, while treating it as an old-school site.⁶ | Opinions split: buyers praise convenience and the warranty, while sellers report low offers, grading disputes, and occasional lost items.10 |
| Biggest gotcha | Peer-to-peer payments only . users warn against PayPal Friends & Family | Condition-grading disputes are the top complaint; inspect on arrival |
Pick FredMiranda when
- Photography hobbyists buying/selling used gear
- Canon/Nikon/Sony shooters seeking gear advice
- Price-checking used lenses before selling
- Long-time forum users
When FredMiranda is not a fit
- Buyers wanting escrow or buyer protection
- Casual sellers unwilling to pay a subscription
- Anyone expecting an app or modern mobile experience
- Non-photographers . it's gear-only
Pick MPB when
- Buyers wanting warranty-backed used gear
- Photographers trading in old kits
- Anyone avoiding eBay buyer/seller risk
When MPB is not a fit
- Sellers maximizing payout . private sales pay more
- Buyers expecting mint condition at used prices
- Price hunters happy to gamble on auctions
Sources
- FredMiranda.com homepagefredmiranda.comofficial
- FM Forumsfredmiranda.comofficial
- Buy and Sell is dying . FM Forumsfredmiranda.comofficial
- Membership Fees . FM Forumsfredmiranda.comofficial
review
- Selling used gear on FredMiranda . DPReviewdpreview.comreview
- FredMiranda.com security pagefredmiranda.comsecurity
- fredmiranda.com on Facebookfacebook.comofficial
- Trustpilot . MPB customer service reviewstrustpilot.comreview
- ResellerRatings . 2,682 MPB reviewsresellerratings.comreview
- Reviews.io . MPB service insightsreviews.ioreview
- Reddit r/canon . Is MPB reputable?reddit.comreview
- Reddit r/Cameras . MPB prices seem highreddit.comreview
official