Comparison

GameFAQs vs Metacritic

GameFAQs

gamefaqs.gamespot.com

Worth it

Confidence: Medium

Use it if you're stuck on an older game and want a fan-written text walkthrough . it's free and still the go-to archive for retro titles.

Read the full report

Metacritic

Starting report…

Pick GameFAQs when

Retro gamers stuck mid-game
Text-walkthrough purists
Completionists hunting obscure titles
Old-school forum dwellers

When GameFAQs is not a fit

Video learners . YouTube walkthroughs fit better
Modern-game players wanting wiki-style quick answers
Anyone allergic to old-school forum culture
Buyers expecting support, SLAs, or anything to purchase

Sources

GameFAQs - Video Game Cheats, Reviews, FAQs, Message Boardsgamefaqs.gamespot.com
official
Even in 2025, I still use GameFAQs - r/retrogamingreddit.com
review
It's honestly impressive that gamefaqs is still running - r/gamefaqsreddit.com
review
GameFAQs is a cesspit and it was time to leave - r/gamefaqsreddit.com
review
Decided to leave gamefaqs after nearly 20 years - r/gamefaqsreddit.com
review
Fandom acquires GameSpot, Metacritic, GameFAQs - TechSpottechspot.com
news
GameFAQs Alternatives - AlternativeToalternativeto.net
review
GameFAQs deleting "negative" PSP Reader Reviews - Nintendo World Reportnintendoworldreport.com
news
What motivates GameFAQs walkthrough authors - ResearchGateresearchgate.net
review
Is Gamefaqs.com down? Live statusdownforeveryoneorjustme.com
security
GameFAQs security pagegamefaqs.gamespot.com
security