Givebutter
Worth it
Confidence: High
Small and mid-size nonprofits get a genuinely free, easy all-in-one fundraising stack worth trying.
Comparison
Givebutter vs Donorbox
Givebutter and Donorbox both land on Worth it.
Donorbox
Worth it
Confidence: Medium
Buy if you run a small nonprofit, church, or PAC that wants fast, well-reviewed donation forms with recurring giving.
| Compare | Givebutter | Donorbox |
|---|---|---|
| Verdict | Worth it | Worth it |
| Best for | Small and mid-size nonprofits | Small nonprofits and churches |
| Who it's not for | Orgs unwilling to show donors 15% tip prompts | Zero-fee purists . Zeffy charges nothing |
| Privacy | PCI-compliant per third-party comparison; no known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.⁸ | PCI DSS Level 1 compliant with a public bug bounty; one patched 2022 XSS in its WordPress plugin. |
| Support quality | No reliable support evidence found | Inconclusive signals in reviewed sources |
| Public sentiment | Users consistently praise ease of use and the free model, while Reddit threads repeatedly warn newcomers about the donor tip feature. | Users broadly praise Donorbox's ease of use and reliability, with recurring complaints about stacked fees and accessibility.12 |
| Biggest gotcha | 15% tip is pre-selected for donors; turning tips off shifts costs to your org. | Free plan still takes 2.95% platform fee plus processor fees . costs add up fast. |
Pick Givebutter when
- Small and mid-size nonprofits
- Peer-to-peer and event fundraising
- Zero-budget teams wanting CRM plus donations
- Orgs replacing multiple fundraising tools
When Givebutter is not a fit
- Orgs unwilling to show donors 15% tip prompts
- Large nonprofits needing enterprise donor management
- Teams wanting flat, predictable SaaS pricing
- Buyers sensitive to donor confusion over where money goes
Pick Donorbox when
- Small nonprofits and churches
- Recurring donation programs
- Political fundraisers and PACs
- Teams wanting fast setup
When Donorbox is not a fit
- Zero-fee purists . Zeffy charges nothing
- Large nonprofits needing full CRM depth
- Orgs with strict WCAG accessibility mandates
- Anyone avoiding tipping/fee-flow controversy
Sources
review
- Givebutter Trustpilot reviewstrustpilot.comreview
review
- Givebutter Fees & Pricinggivebutter.comofficial
- Tips, fees, and transparency . Givebutter Helphelp.givebutter.comofficial
- Compare Givebutter vs DonorPerfectdonorperfect.comreview
- Givebutter Product Security Pagegivebutter.comsecurity
- Givebutter Security Rating . UpGuardupguard.comsecurity
- Givebutter is turning a profit . TechCrunchtechcrunch.comnews
- Givebutter $50M investment announcementprnewswire.comnews
- Donorbox Trustpilot reviewstrustpilot.comreview
- Donorbox G2 reviewsg2.comreview
- Donorbox Ranked #1 Fundraising Software on G2businesswire.comnews
- Donorbox Pricingdonorbox.orgofficial
- Donorbox Trust & Securitydonorbox.orgofficial