shouldiuse.io

New check

Comparison

Gramps-project vs Ancestry

Gramps-project and Ancestry both land on Depends.

Gramps-project versus Ancestry
CompareGramps-projectAncestry
VerdictDependsDepends
Best forSerious hobbyist genealogistsSerious genealogy hobbyists
Who it's not forCasual users who want a quick, pretty family treeCasual hobbyists with a shallow tree
PrivacyOne critical CVSS 9.1 path-traversal CVE in the Gramps Web API (April 2026); desktop app not implicated in reviewed sources.⁷No current public CVEs; past incidents include a 2015 breach and a RootsWeb file exposing 300,000 users.
Support qualityVolunteer-run; forum support onlySupport complaints recur on Reddit, Trustpilot, BBB
Public sentimentUsers praise Gramps as the deepest tool in its category but note it is volunteer-run and divides opinion on usability.⁴Users praise the record depth and tree tools but frequently complain about pricing, auto-renewals, and support.11
Biggest gotchaCVE-2026-40258: Zip Slip path traversal in Gramps Web media import . self-hosters must patch⁷Auto-renewing memberships; BBB records users refused refunds14

Pick Gramps-project when

  • Serious hobbyist genealogists
  • Open-source and offline-first researchers
  • Zero-budget deep family-tree projects
  • Self-hosters wanting a web tree

When Gramps-project is not a fit

  • Casual users who want a quick, pretty family tree
  • Families wanting easy sharing and collaboration
  • Anyone needing vendor support, SLAs, or hand-holding
  • Non-technical users unwilling to tinker

Pick Ancestry when

  • Serious genealogy hobbyists
  • Record-heavy US/UK research
  • DNA match hunters
  • Dedicated family tree builders

When Ancestry is not a fit

  • Casual hobbyists with a shallow tree
  • Budget researchers . free FamilySearch covers basics
  • Privacy-wary users uncomfortable sharing DNA data
  • One-time DNA testers who won't pay monthly

Sources

  1. Gramps (software) . Wikipediaen.wikipedia.org
    official
  2. Gramps-Project.org Costs & Featuresgenealogy-software.no1reviews.com
    review
  3. Gramps-Project.org User Reviewsgenealogy-software.no1reviews.com
    review
  4. Why is Gramps not commonly used? . Reddit r/grampsreddit.com
    review
  5. GRAMPS is the most complete and organized software . Redditreddit.com
    review
  6. Gramps Web Frontend . GitHubgithub.com
    official
  7. GHSA-m5gr-86j6-99jp . Zip Slip Path Traversal advisorygithub.com
    security
  8. CVE-2026-40258 Detail . NVDnvd.nist.gov
    security
  9. Gramps on Snap Storesnapcraft.io
    official
  10. Gramps Reviews . SourceForgesourceforge.net
    review
  11. Trustpilot . Ancestry customer service reviews (36,681)trustpilot.com
    review
  12. Reddit r/Genealogy . Is Ancestry worth it?reddit.com
    review
  13. Reddit r/Genealogy . Ancestry is too damn expensivereddit.com
    review
  14. BBB . Ancestry.com complaintsbbb.org
    review
  15. Family Tree Magazine . Ancestry subscriptions explainedfamilytreemagazine.com
    news
  16. Chicago Tribune . Ancestry reviewchicagotribune.com
    review