Ground Crew Editorial
Depends
Confidence: Medium
Buy if you have a finished fantasy, sci-fi, YA, or MG manuscript and want one-on-one human developmental editing.
New check
Comparison
Ground Crew Editorial vs Reedsy
Ground Crew Editorial and Reedsy both land on Depends.
Reedsy
Depends
Confidence: Medium
Buy if you're self-publishing and ready to pay hundreds-to-thousands for vetted editors and designers.
| Compare | Ground Crew Editorial | Reedsy |
|---|---|---|
| Verdict | Depends | Depends |
| Best for | Fantasy & sci-fi novelists | Self-publishing authors with a real budget |
| Who it's not for | Authors wanting instant, cheap AI line edits | Traditionally published authors |
| Privacy | No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.⁸ | No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed. |
| Support quality | One-on-one model claimed; testimonials self-published, unverified | Invested in AI support tooling; complaints still exist |
| Public sentiment | Client testimonials appear on LinkedIn and Facebook, but reviewed sources contain no verbatim independent review quotes.³ | Reviews are polarized: many authors praise the vetted marketplace and free Studio, while others report bad experiences and question the cost.14 |
| Biggest gotcha | Pricing opaque; only Etsy gift cards ($25-$100) visible, so expect quote-based quotes.⁵ | Scam publishers impersonate Reedsy; verify you're on the official site |
Pick Ground Crew Editorial when
- Fantasy & sci-fi novelists
- YA and MG authors
- Writers wanting one-on-one developmental editing
When Ground Crew Editorial is not a fit
- Authors wanting instant, cheap AI line edits
- Writers needing only a proofread
- Writers outside fantasy/sci-fi/YA/MG focus
Pick Reedsy when
- Self-publishing authors with a real budget
- Debut novelists hiring editors
- Authors outsourcing covers and formatting
- Writers wanting a free drafting tool
When Reedsy is not a fit
- Traditionally published authors
- Zero-budget writers
- Anyone expecting cheap, fast editing
- Hobbyists who just need a word processor
Sources
- Ground Crew Editorial - The Orgtheorg.comofficial
review
review
- Publishing Industry Q&A with Ariane Peveto, Editor at Ground Crewbookedwithkristen.comreview
official
- The Hidden Costs of AI Copyediting Tools: An Editor's Reviewjanefriedman.comnews
- A Book Editor's AutoCrit Review: Is It Good for Novelists?groundcreweditorial.comofficial
- Ground Crew Editorial security pagegroundcreweditorial.comsecurity
- Ground Crew Editorial, Colorado Springs COfindglocal.comofficial
- Reedsy homepagereedsy.comofficial
- Reedsy Studio (free tool)reedsy.comofficial
- Reedsy Studio Pricingreedsy.comofficial
- Reedsy Fees FAQreedsy.comofficial
- Trustpilot reviews of reedsy.comtrustpilot.comreview
- G2 reviews of Reedsyg2.comreview
- Reedsy Reviews . PissedConsumerreedsy.pissedconsumer.comreview