HouseSittersAmerica
Depends
Confidence: Medium
US homeowners get a strong deal: free to join, a one-time fee instead of subscriptions, and a 4.8/5 Feefo rating.
Comparison
HouseSittersAmerica vs MindMyHouse
HouseSittersAmerica and MindMyHouse both land on Depends.
MindMyHouse
Depends
Confidence: Medium
Buy if you're a budget homeowner or sitter in a popular region willing to vet matches yourself.
| Compare | HouseSittersAmerica | MindMyHouse |
|---|---|---|
| Verdict | Depends | Depends |
| Best for | US-only homeowners on a budget | Budget homeowners |
| Who it's not for | International or non-US users | Owners wanting vetted, insured sitters |
| Privacy | No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.⁵ | No known public breaches; site claims fraud-proof system, but fewer built-in protections than larger platforms. |
| Support quality | High Feefo average, but public removal complaints exist | No direct support evidence found |
| Public sentiment | Reviewers position it as a cheaper, US-only alternative to TrustedHousesitters, with mostly strong Feefo scores and a minority of complaint stories.⁶ | Budget-focused users praise the low price and prefer it over pricier rivals, while some report a thin marketplace and uneven sit quality.13 |
| Biggest gotcha | Guess: platform likely doesn't insure sits or mediate disputes; read terms first | No sitter vetting or insurance included . screen candidates yourself⁹ |
Pick HouseSittersAmerica when
- US-only homeowners on a budget
- Sitters open to paid or free sits
- Buyers who hate recurring subscriptions
- Pet owners needing in-home care
When HouseSittersAmerica is not a fit
- International or non-US users
- Anyone wanting the biggest sit network
- People expecting the platform to vet sitters for them (Guess)
- Users unwilling to screen strangers themselves
Pick MindMyHouse when
- Budget homeowners
- Sitters traveling on the cheap
- Long sits in popular regions
- Price-sensitive THS alternatives seekers
When MindMyHouse is not a fit
- Owners wanting vetted, insured sitters
- Rural or low-demand areas . thin sitter pool
- Sitters needing steady sit volume
- Anyone wanting hand-holding support or guarantees
Sources
- House Sitters America: House Sitting in the US | Pet Sittinghousesittersamerica.comofficial
- Home Owner FAQshousesittersamerica.comofficial
- How it works - Pet & house sittinghousesittersamerica.comofficial
- FAQs - House Sittershousesittersamerica.comofficial
- Privacy policyhousesittersamerica.comofficial
review
- House Sitters America Reviews - AVOIDyoutube.comreview
- Find the Best House Sitting Websites 2026: Reviews & Costshousesittingmagazine.comreview
- Best House Sitting Sites in the US (2026): 7 Platforms Rankedhousesittersguide.comreview
- TrustedHousesitters vs House Sitters America: Which Is Best for You?thetravellinghousesitters.comreview
- Best (and Worst) House Sitting Websiteshalftheclothes.comreview
review
- Trustpilot . MindMyHouse reviews (4.7/5, 177 reviews)uk.trustpilot.comreview
- SmartCustomer . MindMyHouse reviews (3.3/5, 16 reviews)smartcustomer.comreview
- House Sitters Guide . MindMyHouse Pricing 2026: $29 a Yearhousesittersguide.comreview
review