Iconoir
Worth it
Confidence: Medium
Buy if you're a designer or developer who wants a genuinely free, MIT-licensed icon set in every format.
Comparison
Iconoir vs Lucide
Iconoir and Lucide both land on Worth it.
Lucide
Worth it
Confidence: Medium
Buy if you are a developer who needs a free, consistent, tree-shakable icon set for web apps.
| Compare | Iconoir | Lucide |
|---|---|---|
| Verdict | Worth it | Worth it |
| Best for | Product designers wanting consistent outline icons | Developers building web UIs |
| Who it's not for | Teams hunting rare, niche icons | Non-developers wanting ready-made graphics |
| Privacy | No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.10 | No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed. |
| Support quality | Community-maintained, donation-funded only | Community only, no SLA evidence |
| Public sentiment | Users like the free, multi-format library but some hit icon-coverage walls and move on.⁴ | Developers praise Lucide's consistency and easy setup, though some switch to rivals like Tabler for more icon variety. |
| Biggest gotcha | Donation-funded via OpenCollective; long-term upkeep rides on volunteer maintainers.⁷ | v1.0 dropped brand icons . audit imports before upgrading |
Pick Iconoir when
- Product designers wanting consistent outline icons
- React and Flutter developers
- Figma and Framer workflows
- Startups wanting zero-cost icons
When Iconoir is not a fit
- Teams hunting rare, niche icons
- Buyers wanting vendor support or SLAs
- Procurement requiring security documentation
Pick Lucide when
- Developers building web UIs
- React, Vue, Svelte projects
- Budget-conscious startups
- Figma-based design teams
When Lucide is not a fit
- Non-developers wanting ready-made graphics
- Apps needing brand or social icons
- Teams wanting one mega-library of every icon style
- Buyers needing paid support guarantees
Sources
- Iconoir GitHub repositorygithub.comofficial
- Iconoir official siteiconoir.comofficial
- Iconoir . Designers Academy reviewdesigners.acreview
review
news
- Iconoir on OpenCollectiveopencollective.comofficial
- iconoir-react on npmnpmjs.comofficial
- iconoir_flutter on pub.devpub.devofficial
- Iconoir security pageiconoir.comsecurity
- Reddit r/vuejs . animated icon librariesreddit.comreview
- Lucide homepagelucide.devofficial
- lucide-icons/lucide GitHub repositorygithub.comofficial
- Lucide Showcaselucide.devofficial
- Lucide React guidelucide.devofficial
official