MemberClicks
Depends
Confidence: Medium
Buy if you run a small-to-mid association or trade group that wants memberships, events, and communities in one system.
Comparison
MemberClicks vs Recur
MemberClicks lands on Depends, and Recur lands on Worth it.
Recur
Worth it
Confidence: Medium
Buy if you run a nonprofit, association, or member-based org that needs dues, renewals, events, and comms in one affordable tool . start free and validate fit.
| Compare | MemberClicks | Recur |
|---|---|---|
| Verdict | Depends | Worth it |
| Best for | Small-to-mid professional associations | Nonprofits and associations |
| Who it's not for | Tiny clubs that just need a member list . spreadsheet territory | Sales teams wanting a deal-pipeline CRM |
| Privacy | No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.⁹ | No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.16 |
| Support quality | No reliable support evidence found | G2 reviewer highlights customer support positively |
| Public sentiment | Aggregator reviews lean positive but snippets are sparse, and independent Trustpilot volume is minimal.¹ | Verified G2 reviewers praise cost and support, but the verified review base is very small and other testimonial evidence is truncated or unverifiable. |
| Biggest gotcha | Pricing not published; Momentive's own page says pricing "varies" . expect a sales negotiation.⁸ | Pricing shown in self-published comparisons; confirm current tiers directly15 |
Pick MemberClicks when
- Small-to-mid professional associations
- Trade associations
- Nonprofits needing memberships plus events
When MemberClicks is not a fit
- Tiny clubs that just need a member list . spreadsheet territory
- Anyone wanting public, self-serve pricing without a sales call
- Regular businesses that aren't membership organizations . wrong category entirely
- Guess: very large associations needing deep enterprise customization
Pick Recur when
- Nonprofits and associations
- Member-based orgs collecting dues
- Groups automating renewals and events
- Orgs priced out of Wild Apricot
When Recur is not a fit
- Sales teams wanting a deal-pipeline CRM
- Small clubs that just need a member spreadsheet
- Guess: large associations needing enterprise reporting and custom integrations
- Buyers unwilling to bet on a vendor with 8 verified reviews
Sources
review
- MemberClicks . Capterracapterra.comreview
- MemberClicks Reviews . Software Advicesoftwareadvice.comreview
- MemberClicks . Trustpilottrustpilot.comreview
- Is MemberClicks Worth It Post-Momentive? . SmartThoughtssmartthoughts.netreview
- MemberClicks . CheckThat.aicheckthat.aireview
- MemberClicks pricing pagememberclicks.comofficial
- MemberClicks . Momentive Software product pagemomentivesoftware.comofficial
- MemberClicks PCI Compliancememberclicks.comsecurity
- MemberClicks security profile . Nudge Securitynudgesecurity.comsecurity
- Recur vs MemberClicks comparisongetrecur.comreview
- VSAE case study . MemberClicksmemberclicks.comofficial
- Recur | Nonprofit Membership Management Softwaregetrecur.comofficial
official
- Recur vs YourMembership: AMS Comparisongetrecur.comofficial
- Product security pagegetrecur.comsecurity