Comparison

Capitally (Mycapitally) vs Sharesight

Capitally (Mycapitally) and Sharesight both land on Depends.
mycapitally.com
Buy if you are a serious DIY investor with messy, multi-currency or illiquid portfolios and $50/yr feels trivial.
Read the full report
sharesight.com
Buy if you're a hands-on investor tracking dividends and tax across multiple brokers and markets; it's well-liked and SOC 2 certified.
Read the full report
Add this comparison to your site
Put the Capitally (Mycapitally) vs Sharesight badge on your site.
Visitors see the independent comparison.
The link points here, and search engines follow it.
This is the badge visitors see on your site.
Paste one snippet. Keep the link as it is. A nofollow tag stops search engines from following it.
Capitally (Mycapitally) versus Sharesight| Compare | Capitally (Mycapitally) | Sharesight |
|---|
| Verdict | Depends | Depends |
|---|
| Best for | Serious DIY investors | Hands-on DIY investors |
|---|
| Who it's not for | Casual investors. A broker app or spreadsheet is enough | Index-fund set-and-forget holders, broker app or spreadsheet is free |
|---|
| Privacy | No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed. | SOC 2 Type 2 certified (May 2025); 2FA offered; no public breach reports found in sources reviewed. |
|---|
| Support quality | Email plus community forum; tiny team | Evidence too thin to score |
|---|
| Public sentiment | Formal reviews are nearly nonexistent; the main user signal is a Reddit mention of the low trial-to-paid price. | Long-tenured Reddit investors across AU, NZ and Canada recommend it, with occasional gripes about manual entry and cost. |
|---|
| Biggest gotcha | Shared-ownership and static-strategy features requested in 2024 remain 'Later', don't rely on them. | Paid plans cited around $19.97/month; verify current regional pricing before committing |
|---|
Pick Capitally (Mycapitally) when
- Serious DIY investors
- Multi-currency portfolios
- Dividend-focused investors
- Private-equity and illiquid asset tracking
When Capitally (Mycapitally) is not a fit
- Casual investors. A broker app or spreadsheet is enough
- Anyone needing a proven vendor, tiny Polish shop, unproven longevity
- Hands-off investors wanting automatic broker sync
- Advisors needing compliance-grade, auditable reporting
Pick Sharesight when
- Hands-on DIY investors
- Dividend and tax reporting needs
- Multi-broker, multi-market portfolios
- Financial advisers managing client portfolios
When Sharesight is not a fit
- Index-fund set-and-forget holders, broker app or spreadsheet is free
- Net-worth and budgeting seekers. It's a tax-report stock tracker, not a money hub
- Anyone balking at a ~$20/mo subscription just to track holdings
- Guess: active day traders, portfolio trackers target long-term holders
Sources
review
review
official
Capitally on Lemon Squeezycapitally.lemonsqueezy.com official
official
official
official
review
review
official
security
review
review
review
review
review