shouldiuse.io

New check

Comparison

MyChart | MyChart is Epic vs Athenahealth

MyChart | MyChart is Epic and Athenahealth both land on Depends.

Athenahealth

athenahealth.com

Depends
Confidence: Medium

athenahealth fits mid-size and large medical groups that want EHR, billing, and patient communication in one cloud platform and can handle opaque, sales-quoted pricing.

Read the full report

MyChart | MyChart is Epic versus Athenahealth
CompareMyChart | MyChart is EpicAthenahealth
VerdictDependsDepends
Best forPatients of Epic-run health systemsMid-size and large medical groups
Who it's not forSmall clinics . Epic is massive overkill; get a light EHR with a portalSolo clinicians wanting a cheap, simple EHR
PrivacyHIPAA-compliant patient portal; one patched 2016 CVE; active phishing impersonation campaigns reported through 2026.⁸HITRUST-certified and HIPAA-compliant, but a November 2024 breach exposed patient data.
Support qualityNo support-quality evidence in reviewed sources.No direct support evidence found
Public sentimentPeer-reviewed patient-experience studies and Reddit threads on accessibility exist, but reviewed snippets offer little verbatim user sentiment.²Public reviews skew sharply negative, with a 1.4/5 Trustpilot score and Reddit complaints about usability and reliability.
Biggest gotchaActive phishing waves impersonate MyChart emails and logins; verify sender addresses before clicking anything.162024 breach may trigger patient-notification and monitoring duties for affected practices.

Pick MyChart | MyChart is Epic when

  • Patients of Epic-run health systems
  • People seen across multiple hospital systems
  • Large hospital networks already on Epic
  • Caregivers managing family records

When MyChart | MyChart is Epic is not a fit

  • Small clinics . Epic is massive overkill; get a light EHR with a portal
  • Patients whose providers don't use Epic . you can't get it
  • Anyone shopping a standalone patient portal . it cannot be bought alone
  • Guess: Teams wanting fast deployment . Epic rollouts run years and millions

Pick Athenahealth when

  • Mid-size and large medical groups
  • Practices wanting billing/RCM handled for them
  • Multi-specialty clinics
  • Behavioral health groups

When Athenahealth is not a fit

  • Solo clinicians wanting a cheap, simple EHR
  • Any non-healthcare business
  • Teams needing transparent, published pricing
  • Anyone wanting self-hosted, in-house data control

Sources

  1. MyChart | MyChart is Epicmychart.org
    official
  2. Patient Experiences and Perspectives When MyChart is Implemented (PMC, 2025)pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
    review
  3. Impacts of Epic MyChart and Healthy Planet on clinical care (BMJ Open, 2026)bmjopen.bmj.com
    review
  4. Epic Systems Review 2026: Pricing, Hyperdrive, EpicCaresaasrat.com
    review
  5. 7 best patient engagement software compared (Birdeye, 2026)birdeye.com
    review
  6. HIPAA-Compliant Patient Portal Options Side-by-Sideliquidweb.com
    review
  7. Epic MyChart Accessibility (Reddit r/healthIT)reddit.com
    review
  8. CVE-2016-6272 Detail . NVDnvd.nist.gov
    security
  9. EPIC MyChart . XPath Injection Exploitexploit-db.com
    security
  10. XPath injection advisory (GitHub)github.com
    security
  11. Medical Records Firm Uses AI Tool to Expose Epic Privacy Flaws (NYT, 2026)nytimes.com
    news
  12. Cass Health Warns Patients of MyChart Phishing Scamcasshealth.org
    news
  13. Avera warns of phishing emails using MyChart nameavera.org
    news
  14. MyChart Scam Targets Patients Nationwide (CampusGuard)campusguard.com
    news
  15. Tampa General rolls out price estimator tool with MyChartbeckershospitalreview.com
    news
  16. Staying safe from scams and fraud (MyChart)mychart.org
    official