shouldiuse.io

New check

Comparison

PrintingCenterUSA vs Printful

PrintingCenterUSA and Printful both land on Depends.

PrintingCenterUSA versus Printful
ComparePrintingCenterUSAPrintful
VerdictDependsDepends
Best forBulk book, calendar & booklet runsCreators launching merch without inventory
Who it's not forOne-off prints . per-unit cost balloons at small quantitiesMargin-chasing resellers who need the cheapest unit costs
Privacy2024 data breach (Mass. #2024-208) and a 2018 consumer information disclosure; publishes a security page.⁶No platform breaches found; Printful's WooCommerce plugin had SSRF flaw CVE-2025-12375 in versions ≤2.2.11.
Support qualityUsers report slow email responsesRecurring complaints on Reddit and Trustpilot
Public sentimentMostly positive on print quality and bulk runs, with recurring complaints about small-quantity pricing and slow support.²Users praise product quality and ease of use but repeatedly complain about pricing, support, and quality-control misses.14
Biggest gotchaBook pricing scales poorly at small quantities . one user paid ~$13 per book for 100 copies²Per-unit costs are the highest among POD rivals; margins suffer at scale

Pick PrintingCenterUSA when

  • Bulk book, calendar & booklet runs
  • Self-publishers with print-ready files
  • Schools, teams & fundraiser organizers
  • Photographers printing portfolios

When PrintingCenterUSA is not a fit

  • One-off prints . per-unit cost balloons at small quantities
  • Buyers needing fast, responsive account support
  • Privacy-sensitive buyers . 2024 breach, 2018 disclosure
  • Non-US buyers . US-based production and shipping

Pick Printful when

  • Creators launching merch without inventory
  • Shopify/Etsy sellers wanting hands-off fulfillment
  • Brands prioritizing quality over unit cost
  • High-volume POD sellers via enterprise tier

When Printful is not a fit

  • Margin-chasing resellers who need the cheapest unit costs
  • Anyone expecting responsive customer support
  • Print shops needing hands-on quality control
  • Teams wanting warehousing or bulk inventory ownership

Sources

  1. PrintingCenterUSA Reviews | Trustpilottrustpilot.com
    review
  2. I Love PrintingCenterUSA...but $1300 for 100 books! . Redditreddit.com
    review
  3. Finding a US based printing company is really hard! . Redditreddit.com
    review
  4. Printing company response times . Redditreddit.com
    review
  5. PoD My Novel . Reddit, r/writersreddit.com
    review
  6. Mass. data breach #2024-208, Crago Inc. d/b/a PrintingCenterUSAmass.gov
    security
  7. Vermont AG . Information Disclosure to Consumersago.vermont.gov
    security
  8. All Printing Products | PrintingCenterUSAprintingcenterusa.com
    official
  9. Sports Program Printing Servicesprintingcenterusa.com
    official
  10. Wholesale Printing | PrintingCenterUSAprintingcenterusa.com
    official
  11. PrintingCenterUSA . BBB Business Profilebbb.org
    review
  12. PRINTINGCENTERUSA.COM . Yelpyelp.com
    review
  13. Printful pricing - Start free, scale when you're readyprintful.com
    official
  14. Read Customer Service Reviews of printful.com . Trustpilottrustpilot.com
    review
  15. Printful Reviews . G2g2.com
    review
  16. I have about had it with Printful. Anyone else? . Redditreddit.com
    review