shouldiuse.io

Comparison

Progressive Insurance vs The Hartford

Progressive Insurance and The Hartford both land on Depends.

The Hartford

Depends
Confidence: Medium

A fit if you're an AARP member 50+ or a small business needing workers' comp, auto, or bundled coverage from a financially solid, 200-year-old carrier.

Add this comparison to your site

Put the Progressive Insurance vs The Hartford badge on your site.

Visitors see the independent comparison.

The link points here, and search engines follow it.

This is the badge visitors see on your site.

Paste one snippet. Keep the link as it is. A nofollow tag stops search engines from following it.

Progressive Insurance versus The Hartford
CompareProgressive InsuranceThe Hartford
VerdictDependsDepends
Best forDrivers wanting fast online quotesAARP members 50+
Who it's not forTeams shopping for software. This is consumer insurance, not a toolBargain hunters wanting published rates, everything is quote-only
PrivacyNo known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.²Legacy insurer with a real incident history: lost tapes affecting 237,000 people, breach-related lawsuits, and a 2025 NY AG settlement.
Support quality24/7 claimed; public outage apology posted219 PissedConsumer complaints; claims gripes recurring
Public sentimentReddit and Facebook threads skew negative.⁵Reviews are mixed: hundreds of ratings on WalletHub and Trustpilot sit alongside 219 complaint-heavy entries on PissedConsumer.13
Biggest gotchaCustomers reported a full day unable to reach support⁷Published 'average cost' guides won't match your actual quote; rates vary widely

Pick Progressive Insurance when

  • Drivers wanting fast online quotes
  • Households bundling auto and home
  • Self-service insurance buyers
  • Budget shoppers comparing rates

When Progressive Insurance is not a fit

  • Teams shopping for software. This is consumer insurance, not a tool
  • Shoppers wanting fixed transparent pricing; quotes vary by profile
  • Anyone needing complex commercial or fleet coverage
  • Buyers sensitive to claims-support complaints on Reddit

Pick The Hartford when

  • AARP members 50+
  • Small businesses needing workers' comp or BOP
  • Trucking and fleet operators
  • Bundlers wanting one carrier for auto, home, business

When The Hartford is not a fit

  • Bargain hunters wanting published rates, everything is quote-only
  • Anyone demanding spotless claims service. 219 complaints logged on PissedConsumer
  • Privacy-sensitive buyers wary of its data-incident history
  • Under-50s excluded from the flagship AARP program discounts

Sources

  1. Progressive homepageprogressive.com
    official
  2. security
  3. review
  4. review
  5. review
  6. review
  7. official
  8. news
  9. review
  10. news
  11. review
  12. 219 The Hartford Reviews | PissedConsumerthe-hartford.pissedconsumer.com
    review
  13. review
  14. review
  15. review
  16. official