New check

Comparison

Punch (Punchapp) vs Clockify

Punch (Punchapp) lands on Depends, and Clockify lands on Worth it.

Punch (Punchapp)

Depends

Confidence: Medium

Buy if you run a small field or service team and want flat-rate GPS time tracking without per-user fees.

Read the full report

Clockify

Worth it

Confidence: High

Buy it if you need cheap, easy time tracking . the free plan alone covers most small teams and freelancers.

Read the full report

Punch (Punchapp) versus Clockify
Compare	Punch (Punchapp)	Clockify
Verdict	Depends	Worth it
Best for	Small field crews (landscaping, trades)	Freelancers billing hourly
Who it's not for	Enterprises needing SSO, audit logs, or compliance docs	Teams needing deep project management
Privacy	No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.^⁹	No public CVEs found against Clockify's core product; it runs a bug bounty.
Support quality	Gmail support address; case-by-case refunds	Lockout complaint plus 1-star Trustpilot reports
Public sentiment	Independent user signal is thin but positive: a Clockify user says they moved all their clients to Punch after free-plan changes.¹⁰	Most users praise Clockify as easy and affordable time tracking, with recurring complaints about access lockouts and basic project features.
Biggest gotcha	Support is a Gmail address; web-subscription refunds handled case-by-case^⁷	One team reported a sudden lockout from their account and rebuilt their own tracker.

Pick Punch (Punchapp) when

Small field crews (landscaping, trades)
Salons and barbershops
Budget teams ditching per-user pricing
Clockify and Homebase switchers

When Punch (Punchapp) is not a fit

Enterprises needing SSO, audit logs, or compliance docs
Tiny teams wanting a real free plan . trial only
Buyers who require independent review scores first
Anyone wanting a full HR and payroll suite

Pick Clockify when

Freelancers billing hourly
Small-to-mid teams wanting free timesheets
Agencies tracking client billables
Nonprofits tracking grant hours

When Clockify is not a fit

Teams needing deep project management
Anyone who can't risk sudden account lockouts
Managers imposing tracking top-down (morale friction)
Buyers uneasy with activity-monitoring features

Sources

Homebase vs Buddy Punch: Pricing and Features (Punch blog)punchapp.io
official
Connecteam Alternative: One Flat-Price App (Punch)punchapp.io
official
Buddy Punch Alternative: Geofencing on Every Plan (Punch)punchapp.io
official
PTO accruals, two new plans, and 15 countries (Punch blog)punchapp.io
official
Free Time Clock Apps: What's Actually Free in 2026 (Punch blog)punchapp.io
official
Time Tracking for Salons and Barbershops (Punch blog)punchapp.io
official
Punch Terms of Servicepunchapp.io
official
Punch Privacy Policypunchapp.io
official
Punch product security page (404)punchapp.io
security
Reddit r/clockify . free plan complaints, Punch switchreddit.com
review
Reddit r/TimeTrackingSoftware . best time tracking 2026reddit.com
review
PunchApp APK (unrelated loyalty app, brand collision)apkpure.com
review
An Honest Review of Clockify (OnTheClock)ontheclock.com
review
Clockify Review: Pros, Cons, Features, Pricing (BuddyPunch)buddypunch.com
review
Honest Clockify Review (Connecteam)connecteam.com
review
ProWorkflow vs Clockifyproworkflow.com
review