Punch (Punchapp)
Depends
Confidence: Medium
Buy if you run a small field or service team and want flat-rate GPS time tracking without per-user fees.
New check
Comparison
Punch (Punchapp) vs ClockShark
Punch (Punchapp) and ClockShark both land on Depends.
ClockShark
Depends
Confidence: Medium
Buy if you run a construction or field-service crew needing GPS clock-ins, job costing, and payroll integrations.
| Compare | ||
|---|---|---|
| Verdict | Depends | Depends |
| Best for | Small field crews (landscaping, trades) | Construction and roofing crews |
| Who it's not for | Enterprises needing SSO, audit logs, or compliance docs | Office-only teams . GPS features wasted |
| Privacy | No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.⁹ | No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed. |
| Support quality | Gmail support address; case-by-case refunds | Human support testimonials, though vendor-published |
| Public sentiment | Independent user signal is thin but positive: a Clockify user says they moved all their clients to Punch after free-plan changes.10 | Reviewers and Reddit users broadly praise ease of use and fit for field crews, while competitors' reviews flag price and mixed construction-user experiences.16 |
| Biggest gotcha | Support is a Gmail address; web-subscription refunds handled case-by-case⁷ | Starts at $40/mo base before per-employee fees; costs climb fast with bigger crews |
Pick Punch (Punchapp) when
- Small field crews (landscaping, trades)
- Salons and barbershops
- Budget teams ditching per-user pricing
- Clockify and Homebase switchers
When Punch (Punchapp) is not a fit
- Enterprises needing SSO, audit logs, or compliance docs
- Tiny teams wanting a real free plan . trial only
- Buyers who require independent review scores first
- Anyone wanting a full HR and payroll suite
Pick ClockShark when
- Construction and roofing crews
- Field service companies with mobile workers
- Job costing by site
- Teams on ADP or Sage payroll
When ClockShark is not a fit
- Office-only teams . GPS features wasted
- Budget buyers wanting a free plan
- Enterprises needing full HCM suites like Rippling
- Very small teams . a spreadsheet or Homebase is cheaper
Sources
official
- Punch Terms of Servicepunchapp.ioofficial
- Punch Privacy Policypunchapp.ioofficial
- Punch product security page (404)punchapp.iosecurity
review
review
- ClockShark . official siteclockshark.comofficial
- ClockShark Pricingclockshark.comofficial
- ClockShark Job Costingclockshark.comofficial
- G2 . ClockShark Reviewsg2.comreview