Setapp vs Shopify App Store

Setapp and Shopify App Store both land on Depends.

Setapp

setapp.com

Depends

Confidence: Medium

Buy it if you're a Mac power user who will genuinely use 3+ bundled apps every month . the math works.

Read the full report

Shopify App Store

apps.shopify.com

Depends

Confidence: Medium

If you run a Shopify store, this is effectively your only app marketplace . use it, but vet each app's reviews, security history, and developer support before installing.

Read the full report

Setapp versus Shopify App Store
Compare	Setapp	Shopify App Store
Verdict	Depends	Depends
Best for	Mac power users juggling many utilities	Active Shopify merchants
Who it's not for	Anyone needing just one or two apps . buy them outright	Anyone not on Shopify . useless outside the platform
Privacy	No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.^⁹	Apps pass Shopify review before listing, but real supply-chain incidents have hit merchants.¹⁵
Support quality	No support evidence in reviewed sources	Per-developer support; abandoned apps reported.
Public sentiment	Reviewers praise the curation and convenience, but Reddit threads endlessly debate whether the subscription pays off if you only need a few apps.^⁴	Merchants value the selection but flag inconsistent app quality, dubious reviews, and abandoned third-party apps.
Biggest gotcha	Setapp Mobile in the EU is shutting down . don't bet on iOS expansion.^⁷	Star ratings can be inflated; dig into review quality before installing.

Pick Setapp when

Mac power users juggling many utilities
Freelancers and writers
People replacing multiple per-app subscriptions

When Setapp is not a fit

Anyone needing just one or two apps . buy them outright
Windows or Linux users . Setapp is Mac-only
Buyers happy with free or open-source alternatives . many bundled apps have them

Pick Shopify App Store when

Active Shopify merchants
Stores adding reviews, upsells, fulfillment
Non-technical owners wanting vetted plug-ins
Merchants wanting central app billing

When Shopify App Store is not a fit

Anyone not on Shopify . useless outside the platform
Buyers who trust star ratings blindly
Teams avoiding subscription creep on monthly bills
Stores needing deep pre-install security vetting

Sources

MacPaw Setapp review: excellent alternative to the App Store . Macworldmacworld.com
review
Setapp customer reviews . Trustpilot (4.4, 244 reviews)trustpilot.com
review
Setapp Reviews . G2g2.com
review
Is Setapp really worth it? . Reddit r/macappsreddit.com
review
Is SetApp worth the subscription fee? . Reddit r/macappsreddit.com
review
Setapp pricing . officialsetapp.com
official
One of the EU's Largest Alternative App Stores Is Shutting Down . TechRepublictechrepublic.com
news
I Replaced these four Setapp apps with free alternatives . Mediummedium.com
review
Is Setapp Safe? . Nudge Security profilenudgesecurity.com
security
Shopify App Store Review 2026: Best and Worstprojectsupply.in
review
Shopify App Storeapps.shopify.com
official
App charges on your Shopify billshelp.shopify.com
official
App Store requirementsshopify.dev
official
Shopify - Wikipediaen.wikipedia.org
official
Insecure Shopify plugin exposed hundreds of storescybernews.com
security
Fast Bundle Security Attackfudge.ai
security