Withjoy
Depends
Confidence: Medium
Choose WithJoy if you want a genuinely free all-in-one wedding site, RSVP, and registry and can tolerate a clunky editor.
New check
Comparison
Withjoy vs The Knot
Withjoy and The Knot both land on Depends.
The Knot
Depends
Confidence: Medium
Couples: yes . the planning, website, and registry tools are free and genuinely useful.
| Compare | Withjoy | The Knot |
|---|---|---|
| Verdict | Depends | Depends |
| Best for | Budget couples wanting a free all-in-one site | Couples planning a wedding on a budget |
| Who it's not for | Couples who want fine design control | Wedding vendors buying ads . repeated price-gouging complaints |
| Privacy | No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.⁹ | No public security page found; user reports of hacked/spammed wedding sites; one XSS disclosure marked patched.14 |
| Support quality | Multiple unresolved-issue complaints on Reddit. | Users report being unable to reach support |
| Public sentiment | Reddit sentiment skews sharply negative . clunky editing, support failures, spam . while third-party reviewers call it a polished free option.¹ | Mixed: couples value the free tools, but Trustpilot sits at 3.4/5 with complaints about support, spam, and review moderation.12 |
| Biggest gotcha | Users report receiving marketing spam instead of expected wedding communications.⁵ | Vendor advertising costs are unpublished and reportedly high . negotiate before committing.15 |
Pick Withjoy when
- Budget couples wanting a free all-in-one site
- Weddings needing RSVP plus registry together
- Couples comfortable troubleshooting tools themselves
- Life-event planning beyond weddings (baby registry)
When Withjoy is not a fit
- Couples who want fine design control
- Anyone needing responsive support near the wedding date
- Privacy-sensitive users wary of marketing emails
- Tech-picky users frustrated by clunky interfaces
Pick The Knot when
- Couples planning a wedding on a budget
- Building a free wedding website + registry
- Cash funds and honeymoon registries
- Browsing a large vendor marketplace
When The Knot is not a fit
- Wedding vendors buying ads . repeated price-gouging complaints
- Privacy-first couples . sites are public unless you lock them down
- Anyone who wants portable content . you build on their platform
- Couples needing only RSVPs . a free form does that
Sources
- Trustpilot reviews of withjoy.com (3.6 average)trustpilot.comreview
review
- Reddit: WithJoy Complaintsreddit.comreview
- Youreventkit: WithJoy Reviewyoureventkit.comreview
- WithJoy pricing pagewithjoy.comofficial
- Joy raises $60M Series Bprnewswire.comnews
security
- The Knot FAQ (free for couples)theknot.comofficial
- The Knot homepagetheknot.comofficial
- The Knot Trustpilot reviewstrustpilot.comreview
- Reddit: The Knot reviews discussionreddit.comreview
- Reddit: wedding website hackedreddit.comreview
- Facebook: vendor price gouging complaintsfacebook.comreview
news