shouldiuse.io

Report

Should I Use Amazonalts?

amazonalts.org·Analyzed 55 minutes ago·Based on 5 sources

Curated list of ethical and sustainable marketplaces to promote alternatives to Amazon

Worth it

Worth it

Use it if you want a free, vetted list of ethical marketplaces instead of Amazon — it's legit and community-endorsed.

Free curated directory of ethical Amazon alternatives — a fine bookmark for shoppers, not a tool anyone buys.

Confidence: Medium

Free

Price

No pricing or signup found

141 upvotes

Launch traction

12 comments on r/ethicalfashion

Legit

Trust check

Scamadviser, 40-factor automated analysis

Value for money5

Free website, nothing to pay

Ease of use4

Small curated list, easy to browse

Feature depth2

Static links only, no tooling

Security posture4

Scamadviser rates it legit and safe

Pros

  • Curated directory of ethical, sustainable marketplaces positioned as Amazon alternatives²
  • Built in-house by activist designers; independent of Amazon⁴
  • Well received at launch: 141 upvotes on r/ethicalfashion²
  • Automated Scamadviser check rates it legit and safe to access¹

Cons

  • A mini database of links — no search, reviews, or buying features²
  • No security page found on the site
  • Side project of a design studio; ongoing upkeep uncertain⁴
  • Promotions date to 2021–2022; listing freshness unverified⁵

Gotchas

  • mediumNo security page — the site informs but doesn't protect your purchases
  • mediumListings surfaced in 2021–2022; verify each marketplace still operates before ordering⁵
  • mediumYou transact with third-party marketplaces — this site bears no accountability for orders or refunds¹

Best for

  • Ethical shoppers quitting Amazon Prime
  • Anti-consumption and sustainable-fashion communities
  • Quick discovery of sustainable marketplaces
  • Zero-cost, zero-commitment browsing

Not for

  • Anyone expecting search, reviews, or checkout — it's just links
  • Shoppers wanting price comparison or fast shipping
  • Teams buying ethics or procurement software
  • People needing maintained, up-to-date listings

Pricing

Free tier: Yes

Security

No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.

What users say

Widely shared in anti-Amazon communities with a warm reception, though most visible commentary is the creator's own promotion.

“a curated list of ethical and sustainable marketplaces to promote alternatives to Amazon”
— Reddit, r/ethicalfashion
“The aim was to spread awareness of the issues with Amazon and find alternative marketplaces that focus on fair working conditions”
— Ariel Saloman portfolio
“This community is for crowdsourcing ethical alternatives to Amazon, sharing news about its shortcomings”
— Reddit, r/CancelAmazonPrime

Alternatives

Compare Amazonalts with each alternative.

Full analysis

Based on 8 public sources; mostly Reddit threads and the creators' own portfolio. No independent hands-on reviews found.

Sources

  1. Scamadviser check for amazonalts.orgscamadviser.com
    security
  2. Reddit, r/ethicalfashion — Amazon Alternatives mini databasereddit.com
    review
  3. Reddit, r/CancelAmazonPrimereddit.com
    review
  4. Ariel Saloman portfolio — Amazon Alternatives case studyarielsaloman.com
    official
  5. Incitement Design on Xx.com
    official

Rate this review

Anonymous. You can change your vote.

Loading votes…

Ask a follow-up

Ask if a use case fits. Answers stay inside this report and its sources.