shouldiuse.io

Report

Should I Use Privacy Guides?

privacyguides.org·Analyzed 1 hour ago·Based on 11 sources

Established in 2021, Privacy Guides is the largest impartial, non-profit media outlet focused on finding privacy tools and learning about protecting your digital life.

Worth it

Worth it

Use it if you're an individual choosing browsers, VPNs, or email and want vetted, ad-free, non-profit recommendations.

Free non-profit privacy guides — great for individuals picking tools; not software, nothing for companies to buy.

Confidence: Medium

2021

Founded

Successor to PrivacyTools

$0

Price

Donation-funded non-profit

Yes

Free tier

All content and forum

3

Paid staff

First full-time hires, 2024

Value for money5

Entirely free, donation-funded, no ads

Ease of use4

Browse freely; forum needs an account

Feature depth4

Tool lists, wiki, learning center, forum

Support quality3

Volunteer forum; moderation complaints exist

Security posture4

Minimal data collection; no public vulns

Pros

  • Non-profit public charity with journalistic standards for recommendations¹
  • All recommendation changes are community-reviewed before publishing²
  • Free learning center teaches threat modeling
  • Large active community forum for privacy questions
  • Ad-free and donation-funded, unlike competitor PrivacyTools

Cons

  • Editorial site only — recommends tools, provides none itself³
  • Trustpilot reviewer alleges moderators remove genuine posts
  • No security or disclosure page found in sources reviewed
  • Content leans on volunteers; only three paid staff as of 2024²
  • Recommendations shift over time; older guidance can go stale

Gotchas

  • mediumRecommended third-party tools carry their own costs and privacy tradeoffs — vet each one separately.³
  • mediumA Trustpilot reviewer says posts get removed; forum help isn't guaranteed.
  • lowGuides get revised; recheck before adopting.
  • lowSustainability depends on donations; no paid tier guarantees longevity.

Best for

  • Individuals picking VPNs, browsers, email
  • Beginners learning threat modeling
  • Privacy enthusiasts comparing tools
  • Donors wanting ad-free non-profit media

Not for

  • Enterprises needing deployable security tooling — it's articles, not software
  • Teams wanting vendor support, SLAs, or invoicing
  • Anyone expecting guaranteed anonymity from a reading list
  • People averse to moderated forums; posts reportedly removed

Pricing

All content

$0

  • Tool recommendations and reviews
  • Guides and learning center
  • Community forum access

Donor

Donation

  • Funds staff and hosting
  • No paywalled content unlocked — same site

Security

No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.

What users say

Reddit users treat it as the successor to PrivacyTools and generally favor its independence, while one Trustpilot reviewer accuses moderators of removing posts.

I would not trust this community.. the remove real written
Trustpilot review
I know Privacy Guides is the new version of Privacy Tools, but even if so, do the recommendations (or at least most of them) in the old site still apply today?
Reddit, r/PrivacyGuides
PrivacyTools has commercial partnerships with many of the service providers listed on their website
Reddit, r/privacy

Alternatives

Compare Privacy Guides with each alternative.

r/privacy

Large community for privacy questions and tool debates

Full analysis

Based on ~30 public sources: official site pages, Reddit threads, Trustpilot, and software directories.

Sources

  1. Privacy Guides homepageprivacyguides.org
    official
  2. About Privacy Guidesprivacyguides.org
    official
  3. official
  4. Privacy Guides Learning Centerlearn.privacyguides.org
    official
  5. Privacy Guides Community Forumdiscuss.privacyguides.net
    official
  6. Donate pageprivacyguides.org
    official
  7. Trustpilot reviewstrustpilot.com
    review
  8. review
  9. review
  10. AlternativeTo listingalternativeto.net
    review
  11. review

Rate this review

Anonymous. You can change your vote.

Loading votes…

Ask a follow-up

Ask if a use case fits. Answers stay inside this report and its sources.