New check

Comparison

DirectoryGems vs Semrush

DirectoryGems and Semrush both land on Depends.

DirectoryGems

directorygems.com

Depends

Confidence: Medium

Buy it if you're an indie builder scouting directory niches and want curated examples with SEO estimates.

Read the full report

Semrush

Depends

Confidence: High

Buy if you run serious, ongoing SEO or agency work and will use most of the toolkit.

Read the full report

DirectoryGems versus Semrush
Compare	DirectoryGems	Semrush
Verdict	Depends	Depends
Best for	Indie hackers building directory sites	SEO agencies and consultants
Who it's not for	Anyone expecting audited, verified traffic data	Hobby sites and side projects
Privacy	No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.^⁹	One CSRF CVE in its WordPress Content Toolkit plugin; no platform breach reported, but scammers heavily impersonate Semrush.
Public sentiment	Early Reddit feedback is positive on organization, but independent reviews are scarce and some users question its legitimacy.^⁵	Reviewers consistently praise its data depth but split hard on whether the price and billing practices justify it.
Biggest gotcha	Subscription price never surfaced in reviewed sources; confirm cost before paying.^³	7-day money-back guarantee reportedly honored inconsistently; one user charged $211¹⁴

Pick DirectoryGems when

Indie hackers building directory sites
Side-project builders seeking niche ideas
SEO hobbyists studying directory monetization

When DirectoryGems is not a fit

Anyone expecting audited, verified traffic data
Teams needing vendor-grade support or SLAs
Buyers wanting a guaranteed playbook, not inspiration
Casual researchers . free Reddit threads may suffice

Pick Semrush when

SEO agencies and consultants
In-house teams running SEO full-time
Brands tracking AI search visibility
Multi-site enterprises

When Semrush is not a fit

Hobby sites and side projects
Anyone needing only basic keyword lookups
Teams that will use two features max
Small businesses without dedicated SEO staff

Sources

DirectoryGems . Directory Research for Buildersdirectorygems.com
official
Hidden Directories. Real traffic. Quiet profits.directorygems.com
official
Directory Website Case Studies & Business Modelsdirectorygems.com
official
The State of Directories . Benchmarks & Datadirectorygems.com
official
DirectroyGems : r/directorymakersreddit.com
review
I just launched DirectoryGems . a curated list of profitable directory websitesreddit.com
review
I built DirectoryGems . a curated database of profitable directories with SEO datareddit.com
review
How I built directorygems.com using AI coding assistantreddit.com
review
Security pagedirectorygems.com
security
Curators as Inventory . CM #35, Robin Goodcurationmonetized.substack.com
news
How to Find Profitable Directory Ideas? . Trends.vctrends.vc
news
Semrush Reviews 2026: G2, Trustpilot, Capterra, Pricingpiperocket.digital
review
Semrush Review (2026): We Tested It on Three Real Sitesgeotoolbox.ai
review
I DO NOT recommend Semrush . money-back guarantee complaintreddit.com
review
Semrush New Prices from 139 to 199reddit.com
review
Semrush Pricing 2026: New Plans & Cost Breakdowndemandsage.com
official