Donorbox
Worth it
Confidence: Medium
Buy if you run a small nonprofit, church, or PAC that wants fast, well-reviewed donation forms with recurring giving.
Comparison
Donorbox vs Fundraise Up
Donorbox lands on Worth it, and Fundraise Up lands on Depends.
Fundraise Up
Depends
Confidence: Medium
Buy it if you're a mid-size or large nonprofit with real online donation volume where AI conversion lifts outweigh a 4% fee.
| Compare | Donorbox | Fundraise Up |
|---|---|---|
| Verdict | Worth it | Depends |
| Best for | Small nonprofits and churches | Large nonprofits with high online-giving volume |
| Who it's not for | Zero-fee purists . Zeffy charges nothing | Small nonprofits . 4% devours small gifts |
| Privacy | PCI DSS Level 1 compliant with a public bug bounty; one patched 2022 XSS in its WordPress plugin.⁶ | No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.13 |
| Support quality | Inconclusive signals in reviewed sources | Free 24/7 support claimed; some user friction |
| Public sentiment | Users broadly praise Donorbox's ease of use and reliability, with recurring complaints about stacked fees and accessibility.¹ | Review-site users praise conversion gains and support, while some Reddit users report integration friction.15 |
| Biggest gotcha | Free plan still takes 2.95% platform fee plus processor fees . costs add up fast. | The 4% fee compounds: one competitor estimates ~$720/year lost on typical volumes |
Pick Donorbox when
- Small nonprofits and churches
- Recurring donation programs
- Political fundraisers and PACs
- Teams wanting fast setup
When Donorbox is not a fit
- Zero-fee purists . Zeffy charges nothing
- Large nonprofits needing full CRM depth
- Orgs with strict WCAG accessibility mandates
- Anyone avoiding tipping/fee-flow controversy
Pick Fundraise Up when
- Large nonprofits with high online-giving volume
- Teams optimizing donation conversion with AI
- Orgs already on Salesforce or HubSpot
- Global fundraising with wallets and local payments
When Fundraise Up is not a fit
- Small nonprofits . 4% devours small gifts
- Anyone wanting a full donor CRM in one tool
- Zero-fee mandates . use Zeffy or Givebutter instead
- Teams unwilling to maintain checkout/integration stack
Sources
- Donorbox Trustpilot reviewstrustpilot.comreview
- Donorbox G2 reviewsg2.comreview
- Donorbox Ranked #1 Fundraising Software on G2businesswire.comnews
- Donorbox Pricingdonorbox.orgofficial
- Donorbox Trust & Securitydonorbox.orgofficial
- CVE-2022-1396 . Donorbox plugin XSSnvd.nist.govsecurity
- Donorbox Tip & Fee Practices Investigationwittelslaw.comnews
- Donorbox Review 2026 (Zeffy)zeffy.comreview
- Reddit r/nonprofit on Donorboxreddit.comreview
- Reddit r/Twitch accessibility threadreddit.comreview
- Fundraise Up official sitefundraiseup.comofficial
- Fundraise Up pricingfundraiseup.comofficial
- Fundraise Up security overviewfundraiseup.comsecurity
- Fundraise Up G2 reviewsg2.comreview
- Fundraise Up Capterra reviewscapterra.comreview
- Fundraise Up Software Advice reviewssoftwareadvice.comreview