Fourthwall
Worth it
Confidence: Medium
Buy if you're a creator or small brand selling merch, memberships, or digital products to an existing audience.
Comparison
Fourthwall vs Gumroad
Fourthwall lands on Worth it, and Gumroad lands on Depends.
Gumroad
Depends
Confidence: Medium
Buy it if you're a first-time creator selling ebooks or digital downloads with zero upfront cost.
| Compare | Fourthwall | Gumroad |
|---|---|---|
| Verdict | Worth it | Depends |
| Best for | YouTubers, streamers, podcasters with existing fans | First-time digital sellers |
| Who it's not for | Enterprise stores needing deep platform depth | High-volume sellers . 10%+ fees compound brutally |
| Privacy | No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.11 | Runs a HackerOne bug bounty, but has a recent CVSS 7.1 missing-authorization CVE and a stored XSS flaw with no known fix. |
| Support quality | Praised service; priority support on Pro | Trustpilot complaints about held funds persist |
| Public sentiment | Creators praise its ease of use and customer service, while reviewers note it lacks depth for enterprise-scale sellers.³ | Creators love Gumroad's simplicity and free setup but widely complain about the ~10-13% effective fees, payout holds, and declining organic sales.16 |
| Biggest gotcha | Zero built-in buyer traffic; without an existing audience expect few sales⁵ | Advertised 10% fee is really ~12.9% once hidden charges land |
Pick Fourthwall when
- YouTubers, streamers, podcasters with existing fans
- Merch plus memberships in one branded shop
- Creators avoiding inventory and upfront costs
- Small brands wanting a storefront without coding
When Fourthwall is not a fit
- Enterprise stores needing deep platform depth
- Sellers wanting built-in buyer discovery . it's no marketplace
- Creators without an existing audience to sell to
- Big retailers with complex catalogs or ops teams
Pick Gumroad when
- First-time digital sellers
- Ebook and template creators
- Testing product ideas cheaply
- No-monthly-fee side hustles
When Gumroad is not a fit
- High-volume sellers . 10%+ fees compound brutally
- Software vendors needing licensing and support tooling
- Thin-margin products where ~13% kills profit
- Sellers who can't risk frozen payouts
Sources
review
review
- Fourthwall for Creators - App Store Reviewsapps.apple.comreview
review
review
review
- Fourthwall Review: The Easiest Way to Launch a Premium Brandecommerce-platforms.comreview
official
- The State of Fourthwall in 2026 - Store Leadsstoreleads.appnews
- Fourthwall Vulnerability Disclosure Programhelp.fourthwall.comsecurity
review
official
- Gumroad's fees . Help Centergumroad.comofficial
- Gumroad Reviews | G2g2.comreview
- Gumroad Reviews | Trustpilottrustpilot.comreview