Macys
Depends
Confidence: Medium
Worth it in-store for major-brand sales if you watch pricing closely.
New check
Comparison
Macys vs Target
Macys lands on Depends, and Target lands on Worth it.
Target
Worth it
Confidence: Low
Low confidence: only one public source was reviewed.
| Compare | ||
|---|---|---|
| Verdict | Depends | Worth it |
| Best for | In-store sale hunters for major brands | Everyday grocery and essentials runs |
| Who it's not for | Anyone saving cards on | Software buyers . this is a store, not a tool |
| Privacy | Checkered record: 2018 breach, 2019 Magecart skimming, Nov 2025 Clop ransomware claim; no security page found.⁸ | No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.13 |
| Support quality | Trustpilot 2.0; service-refusal complaints | No support evidence reviewed |
| Public sentiment | Reviewers rate poorly (Trustpilot 2.0), citing broken online orders, inconsistent pricing, and declining store quality.¹ | No user review sources were available in the evidence reviewed. |
| Biggest gotcha | Three breaches or attacks since 2018 . avoid storing payment info on the site⁷ | Gift card fraud exists; Target advises caution before buying or sharing card numbers13 |
Pick Macys when
- In-store sale hunters for major brands
- Home goods and mattress deal seekers
- Coupon-stacked shoppers
When Macys is not a fit
- Anyone saving cards on macys.com
- Buyers needing reliable online fulfillment
- Trend-focused Gen Z shoppers
- Price-consistency sticklers
Pick Target when
- Everyday grocery and essentials runs
- Contactless pickup or delivery shoppers
- One-stop household and seasonal shopping
When Target is not a fit
- Software buyers . this is a store, not a tool
- Bulk or wholesale shoppers . no warehouse pricing here
- Guess: International buyers . fulfillment is US-centric
Sources
- Read Customer Service Reviews of www.macys.comtrustpilot.comreview
review
- Macy's Online Shopping is Horriblereddit.comreview
review
- Macy's marking up over MSRPreddit.comreview
- Declining Qualityreddit.comreview
- Macy's Online Customers Hit by Magecart Breachinfosecurity-magazine.comsecurity
- Macys.com suffers a data security breachdigitalcommerce360.comsecurity
- Clop Ransomware Attack Hits MACYS.COMdexpose.iosecurity
- Macy's and Sunglass Hut sued over facial recog arresttheregister.comsecurity
news
- Photos: Macy's through the yearswape.comnews
- Product security pagetarget.comsecurity