MaiaLearning
Depends
Confidence: Medium
Buy if you are a US school district replacing Naviance with a full K-12 college-and-career platform.
New check
Comparison
MaiaLearning vs Scoir
MaiaLearning and Scoir both land on Depends.
Scoir
Depends
Confidence: Medium
US high schools, students, and colleges that want one connected planning-to-application network get real value, and it is free for students and families.
| Compare | MaiaLearning | Scoir |
|---|---|---|
| Verdict | Depends | Depends |
| Best for | US K-12 districts replacing Naviance | US high school counseling offices |
| Who it's not for | Individual parents or students buying directly | Students whose high school or counselor is not on Scoir |
| Privacy | No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.10 | No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.16 |
| Support quality | Only indirect hiring evidence, no user reviews | CSMs exist; no independent review data |
| Public sentiment | Student sentiment is mixed: schools lean on it for college lists and counselor workflows, but students publicly report friction and workarounds.⁵ | School-side testimonials are glowing but independent review data is nearly nonexistent, and student sentiment on Reddit skews negative. |
| Biggest gotcha | Pricing is negotiated per district; no free trial advertised, expect a sales cycle¹ | Colleges: verify your tier before signing . pricing jumps from $2,170 toward $26,000.14 |
Pick MaiaLearning when
- US K-12 districts replacing Naviance
- High school counseling departments
- Districts wanting K-5 career exploration included
When MaiaLearning is not a fit
- Individual parents or students buying directly
- Small schools without counseling and procurement staff
- Buyers who need published per-seat pricing
- Independent college consultants . use GuidedPath instead
Pick Scoir when
- US high school counseling offices
- Students at Scoir-connected schools
- Colleges building a student recruitment funnel
- CBOs guiding first-gen applicants
When Scoir is not a fit
- Students whose high school or counselor is not on Scoir
- Colleges that only need application delivery . Common App does that
- Districts wanting the incumbent standard (Naviance dominates)
- Buyers who need independently reviewed support before committing
Sources
- MaiaLearning homepagemaialearning.comofficial
- MaiaLearning Partnerships (Common App)maialearning.comofficial
- Orono Schools MaiaLearning pageoronoschools.orgofficial
- Denver Public Schools MaiaLearning pageccs.dpsk12.orgofficial
- Reddit: Maia learning best hacksreddit.comreview
- Reddit: Maialearning problemreddit.comreview
- DC Urban Mom: accuracy vs Scoirdcurbanmom.comreview
- InsideHigherEd: competition to Navianceinsidehighered.comnews
- MaiaLearning AI features launchlinkedin.comnews
- MaiaLearning security pagemaialearning.comsecurity
- ClearScale web application security case studygo.clearscale.comsecurity
- The Scoir College Networkscoir.comofficial
- Scoir Students and Families Pricingscoir.comofficial
- Scoir College Pricingscoir.comofficial
- Scoir CBO Pricingscoir.comofficial
- Scoir Product Security Pagescoir.comsecurity