Outdoorsy
Depends
Confidence: Medium
Fine for RV owners who want booking demand without marketing and can absorb a ~25% commission.
New check
Comparison
Outdoorsy vs RVshare
Outdoorsy and RVshare both land on Depends.
RVshare
Depends
Confidence: Medium
Fine for a one-off RV trip if you document the rig's condition, understand the deposit options, and accept fee stacking.
| Compare | ||
|---|---|---|
| Verdict | Depends | Depends |
| Best for | RV owners renting out idle rigs | One-off family RV trips |
| Who it's not for | Renters wanting all-inclusive, predictable pricing | Owners of brand-new rigs who can't absorb damage risk |
| Privacy | No known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed. | No confirmed breaches found; one unverified owner-group 'potential security breach' post; DigiSure fraud-vetting partnership in place. |
| Support quality | Widespread complaints about accountability and refunds | Recurring complaints: slow help, cancellation chaos |
| Public sentiment | Reviews are sharply split: many renters and hosts have smooth trips, but a loud, consistent minority report fee surprises and abandoned dispute resolution.¹ | Renters and owners across Reddit, Facebook groups, Trustpilot, and BBB praise the selection but repeatedly report damage disputes, fee stacking, and weak support.13 |
| Biggest gotcha | Host commission starts at 25% and varies . build it into your nightly rate² | Damage disputes can leave you liable even with insurance purchased14 |
Pick Outdoorsy when
- RV owners renting out idle rigs
- One-off family vacation renters
- Owners who won't self-market
- Campervan and trailer trips
When Outdoorsy is not a fit
- Renters wanting all-inclusive, predictable pricing
- Owners unwilling to lose 25% per booking
- Anyone expecting support to resolve damage disputes
- Serious rental businesses . run your own site instead
Pick RVshare when
- One-off family RV trips
- Test-driving RV life before buying
- Owners renting out an idle RV
- Travelers wanting delivery and setup
When RVshare is not a fit
- Owners of brand-new rigs who can't absorb damage risk
- Renters who won't read the insurance and deposit fine print
- Anyone expecting responsive support when a trip goes wrong
- Travelers needing guaranteed refunds on cancelled trips
Sources
- Outdoorsy Trustpilot reviewstrustpilot.comreview
- What fees should I be aware of?support.outdoorsy.comofficial
review
- Outdoorsy: good and badreddit.comreview
- Outdoorsy Reviews & Complaints . ConsumerAffairsconsumeraffairs.comreview
review
- We tried Outdoorsy RV rentals: here's our reviewlovinglifemoore.comreview
- Outdoorsy 2026 Company Profile . PitchBookpitchbook.comnews
- Comparing RVshare and Outdoorsyrvshare.comreview
- Guest FAQs . Outdoorsy payment termssupport.outdoorsy.comofficial
- RVshare homepagervshare.comofficial
- RVshare Review 2026 - Honest Analysisbestrvrentalcompanies.comreview
- RVshare BBB Complaintsbbb.orgreview