shouldiuse.io

New check

Comparison

Create a Personal Price Plan® with State Farm® insurance vs Geico

Create a Personal Price Plan® with State Farm® insurance and Geico both land on Depends.

Geico

geico.com

Depends
Confidence: Medium

Geico fits clean-record drivers hunting low rates and digital self-service, and it ranks No. 1 in US News' ratings.

Read the full report

Create a Personal Price Plan® with State Farm® insurance versus Geico
CompareCreate a Personal Price Plan® with State Farm® insuranceGeico
VerdictDependsDepends
Best forHome-and-auto bundlersClean-record drivers chasing low rates
Who it's not forSelf-serve shoppers who hate agent callsDrivers who want strong claims advocacy
PrivacyNo known public vulnerabilities found in the sources reviewed.⁸Fined $11.3M in Nov 2024 for lax data security after hackers fraudulently accessed customer accounts; earlier breach led to a class action.15
Support qualityComplaint sites document claims and cancellation frictionClaims and service complaints recur across review sites
Public sentimentIndependent review coverage centers on complaints about claims and cancellations, while most other sources are agent marketing posts.⁴Reviews are sharply polarized: raters rank Geico top for price while many customers complain bitterly about claims and service.⁹
Biggest gotchaQuotes are state-specific; moving means re-pricing from scratch.²Hackers used stolen driver's-license numbers to access customer accounts; NY fined Geico and Travelers15

Pick Create a Personal Price Plan® with State Farm® insurance when

  • Home-and-auto bundlers
  • Buyers who want a local agent
  • RV, condo, multi-policy owners
  • People who want annual coverage check-ins

When Create a Personal Price Plan® with State Farm® insurance is not a fit

  • Self-serve shoppers who hate agent calls
  • Anyone wanting instant transparent online pricing
  • Shoppers in states where quotes run high
  • Anyone comparing software . this is personal insurance, not a tool

Pick Geico when

  • Clean-record drivers chasing low rates
  • Digital-first customers who self-serve
  • Drivers bundling multiple vehicles and policies

When Geico is not a fit

  • Drivers who want strong claims advocacy
  • Privacy-sensitive buyers (data-security fines)
  • Anyone wanting agent-run, full-service insurance

Sources

  1. State Farm agent Personal Price Plan page (Philadelphia)phillyinsured.com
    official
  2. Let's create your Personal Price Plan (agent flyer)resources.finalsite.net
    official
  3. State Farm Life Insurance Company SEC filing (payment plan terms)sec.gov
    official
  4. State Farm Insurance Reviews: Complaints, Pros and Conshelp-center.pissedconsumer.com
    review
  5. How State Farm home/auto consumer complaints workiotserver4g.trumeter.com
    review
  6. Personal Price Plan overview (Instagram aggregator)instagram.com
    review
  7. US Ad of the Day: State Farm Personal Price Plan campaignthedrum.com
    news
  8. State Farm product security pagestatefarm.com
    security
  9. GEICO Car Insurance Review for 2026 . US Newsusnews.com
    review
  10. Progressive vs. Geico . LendingTreelendingtree.com
    review
  11. GEICO Insurance Reviews . WalletHubwallethub.com
    review
  12. Trustpilot reviews of geico.comtrustpilot.com
    review
  13. My experience with GEICO . Redditreddit.com
    review
  14. Geico, Travelers fined $11.3M . Dark Readingdarkreading.com
    security
  15. NY AG press release on $11.3M auto-insurer fineag.ny.gov
    security
  16. GEICO Data Breach Class Action . KGGLawkgglaw.com
    security